Return-Path: <scs@eskimo.com>
Received: from pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id MAA04602; Thu, 20 Dec 2001 12:05:21 -0500 (EST)
Received: from mail.eskimo.com (mail.eskimo.com [204.122.16.4])
	by pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id MAA08565
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu>; Thu, 20 Dec 2001 12:04:46 -0500 (EST)
Received: from eskimo.com (scs@eskimo.com [204.122.16.13])
	by mail.eskimo.com (8.9.1a/8.8.8) with ESMTP id IAA12816;
	Thu, 20 Dec 2001 08:59:34 -0800 (PST)
Date: Thu, 20 Dec 2001 08:59:34 -0800 (PST)
Message-Id: <200112201659.IAA12816@mail.eskimo.com>
From: scs@eskimo.com (Steve Summit)
Reply-To: scs@eskimo.com
To: carolr@informix.com, nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu
Subject: stuff you probably never knew about horses
References: <u1vng4dq9pen18@corp.supernews.com> <m16GYof-000grCC@shell.vex.net>

[Forwarding headers *not* deleted; this was first posted to the
net by robgood@bestweb.net.]

From: robgood@bestweb.net
Newsgroups: alt.fan.cecil-adams
Subject: term paper folly (long)
Date: Wed, 19 Dec 2001 00:23:32 -0000
Message-ID: <u1vng4dq9pen18@corp.supernews.com>

In general in the fall of 2001 the term papers I got in my Mercy
College Evolution course were a pleasant surprise.  One of them
was the best I've ever read (and original), and others were very
good.  However, I did get one absolute clunker.  It got more and
more unintentionally funny as it went on.

Its cover page had in huge type, "Evoluion", then my name and its
title, "Evolution of Horses", and author who shall be anonymous
here.  The top of the first page said, underlined and in bold
face, "The Evolution of Horses", and skipping several lines
centered underneath it, "By George Gaylord Simpson", and under
that, "1961".  I puzzled for a while, wondering whether the
student was admitting this was plagiarized, or thought this was
to be a book review, or what.  Eventually I realized this was her
reference.  In the body, she had parenthetic page references and
no other source mentioned, so this must be the most misleading
placement I've ever seen for a bibliography -- where the title
should be.  This is verbatim, with spelling, punctuation,
capitalization, and a spurious line break authentic:

****************************************************************

          Two Great Runners: The Eohippus And The Equus

    In this term paper I will focus on two types of horses.  The
Eohippus horse is a Wild horse and the Equus is a domestic horse.
We use horses for racing and for domestic use like forming and
traveling to get around.  The characteristic of a house may be
describe as a donkey or a zebra.  Many years ago, the story have
been told of how horses are related to donkeys and zebras.
Devoted scientist have searched in the sun looking for fossils to
study in museums, universities and laboratories. (Page 217)
Curiosity has made scientist wonder and very curious as to how
horses trot.  One scientist bought a camera to take pictures.
Another scientist was curious about how horses were such great
runners.  Curiosity bought about a campaign for collecting
fossils.  These men had an interest in testing the theory of
evolution in horses.
    Darwin has a theory back in the days
that evolution is the key to the history of life.  He also
believed that domestic animals and wild animals were similar.
(Page 218)  One of the ways scientists found evidence of
evolution, was by looking at the remains of fossils record.
Scientist of the 19th century were courious about finding fossils
of different ages that would back up the theory of evolution
(Page 222).
    There was a many name William Jennings Bryan.  Well, Mr.
Bryan was against Dowins theory of evolution.  He had no concern
for factual evidence on evolution.  He said "he would believe in
the theory of evolution when he could sit down in his garden and
see an onion turn into a lily" By studying fossils records we can
see that evolution is a fact. (Page 223)  One might ask why is it
so important to keep searching for fossils?  The reason is to
increase our knowledge of the earth and life.

                 The Changing Of Skull And Brain

    Knowing that animals are organisms, it as a known fact
because it's a body.  Parts of the organisms and divided into
units.  In other words, the body needs is organism units to work
together. (Page 232)  In the eohippus the eye is almost in the
middle of the head.  The face is in front of the eyes.  The Eqqus
has a very long face twice as long as the cranium.  The brain is
made up of soft tissue, it decays very fast.  Although minor
details may be lacking about the brains after the brain has
decayed the skull gets full with mud. (Page 235)  A Eohippus has
a very primitive brain.  Its brain is more like a reptile rather
than a normal mammal.  One of the most important feature about
brain evolution in mammals is intelligence.  Yet, the brain of
the Eohippus seems to be a very stupid animals. (238)

                      The Changing Of Teeth

    The teeth of the horse are the best feature known about their
evolution.  for example, the teeth work together as a unit with
other parts of the body.  It's function is to crush and grind
food.  It helps in swallowing food with saliva for better
digestion. (Page 241)  Eohippus horses teeth have cheek teeth.
Their teeth are for eating soft leafy vegetables.  In order to
survive they must have the ability to eat a larger variety of
foods.  A horses teeth must last a very long tim if it's going to
Survive and eat.  The main change in a horse's teeth is their
size, pattern and crown height.  A horse has three molars and
four premolars.  The Molars are square, which is what the hoses
mostly thew on.  Premolars are triangular and smaller than
molars. (Page 244)  Equus has very high crowns but it's height
was limited three times it's length of the tooth.

                         Limbs and Feet

    All horses domestic and wild are runners.  Speed is their
most valuables asset.  Running is a way of life for horses, speed
means freedom and enjoying life.  The Eohippus and dogs are very
much similar in size and build.  But the Eohippus front legs are
shorter and their legs are longer.  Both have very good speed.
The Equus does not run faster than the Eohippus this is because
the limbs of the Eohippus is always faster.  If an Eohippus had
sixteen legs instead of four legs it would present a serious
problem.  For example, it wouldn't be able to run as fast and it
could break its legs. It's weight and height would be to heavy on
his bones.  Its muscles wouldn't be able to hold him up. (Page
253)  Eohippus had four toes on one foot in the early days.
Later they had three toes on one foot.  The wrist corresponds
with the hock.  Below the end of the these bones and in between
and behind the toes is a tough flexible cushion. (Page 256)
Later doing the course of evolution the though of changes in
horses leg became an idea.  Scientist thought of changing their
legs in proportions by size.  For example, making their upper
legs bones shorter and their lower legs longer.  But, because of
their speed this would present a real problem.  Now they would be
much slower because of their heaviness.

*************************************************************

It doesn't look like she even realizes Eohippus is long extinct.
I should ask her where she found that book.  The omission of "r"
twice from "brought" was funny, but just a misspelling after all.
The business about the "eye...almost in the middle of the head" I
can explain as miscommunication, but how could she have gotten
such an absurd thought in her head as concerning hypothetic 16-
legged horses?  I'm not sure if she thought scientists are re-
engineering horses and taking ideas out of the suggestion box.
However, one contradictory sentence might've gotten that way just
by the word "back" or "hind" being omitted at the point
indicated: "But the Eohippus front legs are shorter and their *
legs are longer."  The passage about the teeth is confusing, but
might reflect actual facts.

Overall it looks like the product of collaboration between a 3rd
grader and a lunatic, translated into Chinese and back.  She does
appear dumb in class, asking childish or vague questions.  She
failed the midterm exam, missed an earlier quiz, and the final
exam is next class, when I'll hand this paper back to her.

I might give her F for just such misunderstanding and
miscommunication of science, let alone bizarre ideation.
However, I'm thinking of giving her D or maybe even C on the
basis of form.  Apparently she's done some reading on the subject
and brought out certain facts, albeit in twisted form.  Her
organization is actually fairly good.  And she did cite her
source, albeit disconcertingly; many students, though I explain
my requirement very carefully, don't footnote the text, but she
did.

In the past I've given F only for papers that were practically
gibberish.  In a way this one is worse, because I can understand
enough of it to reveal its craziness.

Robert
