Return-Path: <ngreenberg@DLRGROUP.com>
Received: from pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id RAA16030; Mon, 17 Sep 2001 17:53:16 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from mail.dlrgroup (mail.dlrgroup.com [12.10.17.82])
	by pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id RAA06832
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@MIT.EDU>; Mon, 17 Sep 2001 17:48:33 -0400 (EDT)
Received: by MAIL with Internet Mail Service (5.5.2653.19)
	id <RFK1VM5G>; Mon, 17 Sep 2001 16:49:06 -0500
Message-ID: <A9F8FC888937D511A60800508B9A7119A67970@DLRMAIL>
From: "Greenberg, Noah" <ngreenberg@DLRGROUP.com>
To: "'nutso-flaming-pikans@mit. edu' (E-mail)"
	 <nutso-flaming-pikans@MIT.EDU>
Subject: FW: Let's try this
Date: Mon, 17 Sep 2001 16:46:30 -0500
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Mailer: Internet Mail Service (5.5.2653.19)
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
	boundary="----_=_NextPart_001_01C13FC2.35FC0A40"

This message is in MIME format. Since your mail reader does not understand
this format, some or all of this message may not be legible.

------_=_NextPart_001_01C13FC2.35FC0A40
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"

 
i like this one
 
- noah
 

This was sent to me by a friend.  I thought you would appreciate it, and
agree. 

RETALIATION--A MODEST PROPOSAL 

For the past two days, since the fateful events of the morning of 
September 11, we have been considering what should be done.  It has 
generally been assumed that when we discovered the identities of the 
perpetrators, we would make some effort to bring them before our courts, 
and that when that failed, we would bring the full force of our military 
to bear on them, and on those who harbor them.  If we, as a nation, are 
to show true leadership in the fight against terrorism, we must indeed 
be forceful.  But if our fight is to have any hope of success, we must 
also be creative.  We must think outside Hammurabi's box in our pursuit 
of justice, and peace. 

Our tremendous ingenuity as a species seems strangely absent when it 
comes to confronting threats from each other. Failed strategies are 
repeated, and repeated, though history has demonstrated their futility.   
Athenian treatment of the Melians did not win them the Peloponnesian 
War.  The American Civil War was won before Sherman's torching of 
Atlanta, not because of it.  Our Israeli friends have gained nothing 
from their policy of collective punishment--not only have they failed to 
make peace with their neighbors, or even to guarantee their own safety, 
they have implicated their allies.  The efforts of Palestinian militants 
now seem less likely than ever to win for their families the safe and 
secure hearths we all desire. 

Our reactions to violence are repeated with such dismal regularity 
because they are instinctive.  But we are not, or not exclusively, 
creatures of instinct.  Can we do better? Perhaps.  First we must ask 
what we hope to gain from our response to Tuesday's attacks.  What we 
want, it seems, is to end the threat of terrorism, to restore our 
feelings of safety, to assert our national self-confidence, and yes, to 
impress upon the world the extent of our wealth and power.  The 
following proposal has, I believe, a good chance of helping to achieve 
all of these goals.  It provides no guarantee of an end to the 
violence--and the only such guarantee within our power is the complete 
destruction of humanity--but it offers some hope of relief from the 
cyclic destruction of the past. 

Like other solutions now being contemplated, this proposal will be 
massive, expensive, and dangerous for the service personnel whose task 
it will be to implement it.  It will involve harnessing the full 
resources of our military, and the vast riches of our civilian economy.   
It will take some time to prepare. 

Once preparations are complete, here is how I envision it working:  our 
bombers fly low over Kabul, Qandahar, Gaza, Aman, Khartoum, Bagdad, 
Beirut,  over all the surrounding countryside, over villages and refugee 
camps.  They will be in harm's way, but we will not ask them to linger. 

Their bomb bays open, jettisoning their cargo, and our planes return 
swiftly to base for reloading.  Below their fading contrails, parachutes 
appear, each supporting a crate.  When these touch ground, there will 
perhaps be some panic.  But when the crates fail to explode, the daring 
and curious approach, ready to prize them open.  Here is what they will 
find:  water purifiers, iodine tablets, baby formula, portable 
generators, machine tools, farm implements, olives, salt, shoes, cloth, 
school books, copies of the Koran, antibiotics, antimalarials, 
antiseptics, rice, radios, kerosene heaters, power cable, sewing 
machines, calculators, batteries, solar panels, diapers, safety pins, 
hair pins, bicycles, candy, toothbrushes, sunscreen, saffron, dried 
apricots, notebooks, ledgers, ball-point pens, refrigerators, baby 
bottles, stoves, art supplies, soccer balls, tents, telescopes, and 
blankets. 

There will be some who, in anger or disdain, incite their neighbors to 
gather our gifts and burn them.  In the end, though, as wave after wave 
of cargo arrives, more practical voices will prevail. Consumables will 
not, of course, last forever.  But the other things may make a 
difference for years to come, especially if, like the Berlin Airlift, 
they are followed with a Marshall Plan. 

In recent years, in our strategic bombardments of Iraq or Serbia, we 
have talked about "sending a message," to Saddam Hussein, or to 
Milosevic.  The truth is, a bomb casing is a poor housing for any 
message worth listening to.  We must tell those who despise us more than 
merely, if they cross us, we will destroy them.  We must tell them that, 
if the world order from which we profit is oppressive to them, that was 
never our intention, that what we desire for them is nothing less than 
the liberty and prosperity we ourselves enjoy. 

It is also true that people with nothing left to lose will always, 
inevitably behave like people with nothing left to lose.  Force and the 
threat of force have no hold over them.  It is within our power to do 
with our largesse what can never be done with arms. 

No political leader who follows this course of action will ever be 
accused of weakness, or failure to act decisively. Indeed it strikes me 
as demanding courage of the highest order. 

It is possible that, given the title of this proposal, or its contents, 
or the admitted and unabashed sentimentality of its tone, it will be 
taken in the spirit of jest.  If so, that is not a bad thing.  In times 
like these, we all need something to laugh about.  But if there are 
those who find in this notion, or others like it, something more than a 
melancholy joke, then that is a better thing.  To lose hope for a better 
world is to live in a worse one. 

Peace and Love. 

Alex Levine 

------_=_NextPart_001_01C13FC2.35FC0A40
Content-Type: text/html;
	charset="iso-8859-1"

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD>
<META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">


<META content="MSHTML 5.00.3103.1000" name=GENERATOR>
<STYLE></STYLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY bgColor=#ffffff>
<DIV style="FONT: 10pt arial">
<DIV>&nbsp;</DIV>
<DIV><FONT color=#0000ff><SPAN class=150514221-17092001>i like this 
one</SPAN></FONT></DIV>
<DIV><FONT color=#0000ff><SPAN 
class=150514221-17092001></SPAN></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV>
<DIV><FONT color=#0000ff><SPAN class=150514221-17092001>- 
noah</SPAN></FONT></DIV>
<DIV>&nbsp;</DIV></DIV>
<DIV><BR></DIV><FONT face=arial,helvetica><FONT face="Lucida Bright" lang=0 
size=2 FAMILY="SERIF">This was sent to me by a friend. &nbsp;I thought you would 
appreciate it, and agree. <BR><BR>RETALIATION--A MODEST PROPOSAL <BR><BR>For the 
past two days, since the fateful events of the morning of <BR>September 11, we 
have been considering what should be done. &nbsp;It has <BR>generally been 
assumed that when we discovered the identities of the <BR>perpetrators, we would 
make some effort to bring them before our courts, <BR>and that when that failed, 
we would bring the full force of our military <BR>to bear on them, and on those 
who harbor them. &nbsp;If we, as a nation, are <BR>to show true leadership in 
the fight against terrorism, we must indeed <BR>be forceful. &nbsp;But if our 
fight is to have any hope of success, we must <BR>also be creative. &nbsp;We 
must think outside Hammurabi's box in our pursuit <BR>of justice, and peace. 
<BR><BR>Our tremendous ingenuity as a species seems strangely absent when it 
<BR>comes to confronting threats from each other. Failed strategies are 
<BR>repeated, and repeated, though history has demonstrated their futility. 
&nbsp; <BR>Athenian treatment of the Melians did not win them the Peloponnesian 
<BR>War. &nbsp;The American Civil War was won before Sherman's torching of 
<BR>Atlanta, not because of it. &nbsp;Our Israeli friends have gained nothing 
<BR>from their policy of collective punishment--not only have they failed to 
<BR>make peace with their neighbors, or even to guarantee their own safety, 
<BR>they have implicated their allies. &nbsp;The efforts of Palestinian 
militants <BR>now seem less likely than ever to win for their families the safe 
and <BR>secure hearths we all desire. <BR><BR>Our reactions to violence are 
repeated with such dismal regularity <BR>because they are instinctive. &nbsp;But 
we are not, or not exclusively, <BR>creatures of instinct. &nbsp;Can we do 
better? Perhaps. &nbsp;First we must ask <BR>what we hope to gain from our 
response to Tuesday's attacks. &nbsp;What we <BR>want, it seems, is to end the 
threat of terrorism, to restore our <BR>feelings of safety, to assert our 
national self-confidence, and yes, to <BR>impress upon the world the extent of 
our wealth and power. &nbsp;The <BR>following proposal has, I believe, a good 
chance of helping to achieve <BR>all of these goals. &nbsp;It provides no 
guarantee of an end to the <BR>violence--and the only such guarantee within our 
power is the complete <BR>destruction of humanity--but it offers some hope of 
relief from the <BR>cyclic destruction of the past. <BR><BR>Like other solutions 
now being contemplated, this proposal will be <BR>massive, expensive, and 
dangerous for the service personnel whose task <BR>it will be to implement it. 
&nbsp;It will involve harnessing the full <BR>resources of our military, and the 
vast riches of our civilian economy. &nbsp; <BR>It will take some time to 
prepare. <BR><BR>Once preparations are complete, here is how I envision it 
working: &nbsp;our <BR>bombers fly low over Kabul, Qandahar, Gaza, Aman, 
Khartoum, Bagdad, <BR>Beirut, &nbsp;over all the surrounding countryside, over 
villages and refugee <BR>camps. &nbsp;They will be in harm's way, but we will 
not ask them to linger. <BR><BR>Their bomb bays open, jettisoning their cargo, 
and our planes return <BR>swiftly to base for reloading. &nbsp;Below their 
fading contrails, parachutes <BR>appear, each supporting a crate. &nbsp;When 
these touch ground, there will <BR>perhaps be some panic. &nbsp;But when the 
crates fail to explode, the daring <BR>and curious approach, ready to prize them 
open. &nbsp;Here is what they will <BR>find: &nbsp;water purifiers, iodine 
tablets, baby formula, portable <BR>generators, machine tools, farm implements, 
olives, salt, shoes, cloth, <BR>school books, copies of the Koran, antibiotics, 
antimalarials, <BR>antiseptics, rice, radios, kerosene heaters, power cable, 
sewing <BR>machines, calculators, batteries, solar panels, diapers, safety pins, 
<BR>hair pins, bicycles, candy, toothbrushes, sunscreen, saffron, dried 
<BR>apricots, notebooks, ledgers, ball-point pens, refrigerators, baby 
<BR>bottles, stoves, art supplies, soccer balls, tents, telescopes, and 
<BR>blankets. <BR><BR>There will be some who, in anger or disdain, incite their 
neighbors to <BR>gather our gifts and burn them. &nbsp;In the end, though, as 
wave after wave <BR>of cargo arrives, more practical voices will prevail. 
Consumables will <BR>not, of course, last forever. &nbsp;But the other things 
may make a <BR>difference for years to come, especially if, like the Berlin 
Airlift, <BR>they are followed with a Marshall Plan. <BR><BR>In recent years, in 
our strategic bombardments of Iraq or Serbia, we <BR>have talked about "sending 
a message," to Saddam Hussein, or to <BR>Milosevic. &nbsp;The truth is, a bomb 
casing is a poor housing for any <BR>message worth listening to. &nbsp;We must 
tell those who despise us more than <BR>merely, if they cross us, we will 
destroy them. &nbsp;We must tell them that, <BR>if the world order from which we 
profit is oppressive to them, that was <BR>never our intention, that what we 
desire for them is nothing less than <BR>the liberty and prosperity we ourselves 
enjoy. <BR><BR>It is also true that people with nothing left to lose will 
always, <BR>inevitably behave like people with nothing left to lose. &nbsp;Force 
and the <BR>threat of force have no hold over them. &nbsp;It is within our power 
to do <BR>with our largesse what can never be done with arms. <BR><BR>No 
political leader who follows this course of action will ever be <BR>accused of 
weakness, or failure to act decisively. Indeed it strikes me <BR>as demanding 
courage of the highest order. <BR><BR>It is possible that, given the title of 
this proposal, or its contents, <BR>or the admitted and unabashed sentimentality 
of its tone, it will be <BR>taken in the spirit of jest. &nbsp;If so, that is 
not a bad thing. &nbsp;In times <BR>like these, we all need something to laugh 
about. &nbsp;But if there are <BR>those who find in this notion, or others like 
it, something more than a <BR>melancholy joke, then that is a better thing. 
&nbsp;To lose hope for a better <BR>world is to live in a worse one. 
<BR><BR>Peace and Love. <BR><BR>Alex Levine</FONT> </FONT></BODY></HTML>

------_=_NextPart_001_01C13FC2.35FC0A40--
