Return-Path: <jwlandry@midway.uchicago.edu>
Received: from pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id PAA14004; Wed, 27 Mar 2002 15:56:32 -0500 (EST)
Received: from midway.uchicago.edu (midway.uchicago.edu [128.135.12.12])
	by pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id PAA19025;
	Wed, 27 Mar 2002 15:52:08 -0500 (EST)
Received: from harper.uchicago.edu (daemon@harper.uchicago.edu [128.135.12.7])
	by midway.uchicago.edu (8.11.6/8.11.6) with ESMTP id g2RKq8r19743;
	Wed, 27 Mar 2002 14:52:08 -0600 (CST)
Received: (from jwlandry@localhost)
	by harper.uchicago.edu (8.11.6/8.11.6) id g2RKq8H08699;
	Wed, 27 Mar 2002 14:52:08 -0600 (CST)
Date: Wed, 27 Mar 2002 14:52:08 -0600
From: james william landry <jwlandry@uchicago.edu>
To: Corrina Chase <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Cc: nutso-flaming-pikans@MIT.EDU
Subject: Re: Fidel's assertions
Message-ID: <20020327145207.A15509@harper.uchicago.edu>
References: <200203271949.OAA28626@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1
Content-Disposition: inline
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
User-Agent: Mutt/1.2.5i
In-Reply-To: <200203271949.OAA28626@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>; from corrina@MIT.EDU on Wed, Mar 27, 2002 at 02:51:24PM -0500

I'm sorry, but this isn't persuasive to me.  What you are saying is that
most areas in the world have decreased poverty as a
percentage of the population.  If I understand your other statement,
Central Asia has seen its poverty level increase by 5%.  That suggests
that people are getting richer on average and poverty levels are
declining.  As for Central Asia, it has very little trade with the world
market and is largely insulated from the world financial system, either
because of war or because of decades of Communist central planning.  So
you would need further evidence to convince me that increasing poverty
in Central Asia is an effect of the world financial system.  And also, 
this is only for a ten year period.  What about
the last fifty or a hundred years?  What were poverty levels like in
China in 1900?  I can almost guarantee that the average East Asian is
markedly better off in terms of access to clean water, food, shelter,
and health care now than in the year 1900.

Widening inequality is a real issue, but it is not necessarily the same
issue as access to clean water, food, shelter, and health care.  You
haven't provided any evidence to link these things.  You
also have an article about hunger, which I basically agree with.  Hunger 
is essentially a political
problem.  For example, famines basically ended in India once the
British were forced out and democracy was instituted, because the
British didn't care if lots of Indians starved to death, while
democratically elected Indian representatives emphatically did care.
You haven't presented any link between the world financial system and
hunger.  In Zimbabwe for example, hunger is a real problem precisely
because Mugabe has decided to defy first world opinion and steal
elections and ruin the economy through corruption.  Many other African
governments support him and are complicit in his attempts to starve his
own people.  I don't see how hunger in Zimbabwe has much to do with the
world financial system, or with US or EU policy in other countries.  (As
a side note, this is also why biotechnology and Monsanto are totally
unnecessary and frequently harmful - we've got plenty of food.  We just 
need to work on distribution.)

I'll say it again.  I'm fully cognizant that the current financial
system has not helped many countries escape widespread poverty and in
many cases has exacerbated their problems.  I see no evidence that
Castro, by harping on inequality, has any ideas to change the current
sytem or alleviate poverty in other countries.  I don't even really see
evidence that Castro has any ideas about solving the problems in Cuba
after the fall of the Soviet Union and the end of subsidies to his
government.  So why should we care about little speeches he gives,
especially when he is an authoritarian who does not allow independent
political and social expression? 

I'm perfectly willing to listen to people who have ideas about these
things and how to change them.  I don't really think Castro qualifies.

James
 
* Corrina Chase <corrina@MIT.EDU> [020327 13:49]:
> James, Here are a few facts to set you straight:
> According to even the world bank, the number of poor people have increased by
> 100.9 million people from 1987-1998 and in percentages of population, Central
> Asia has risen by 5%.  Using this definition of poor, other geographical areas
> have decreased this percentage, but these statistics defines "poor" as "living
> on less than $1.09 a day.  This tends to lead to an inaccurate view of what
> poverty actually exists because poverty is better defined as access to basic
> needs such as clean water, food, shelter, and health care.  The gap between
> the
> wealthiest people of our world and the poorest is growing much wider.  I don't
> have time to dig for much more than the following:
> 
> http://www.globalissues.org/TradeRelated/Facts.asp#2
> Highlights:
> An analysis of long-term trends shows the distance between the richest and
> poorest countries was about :
> 3 to 1 in 1820
> 11 to 1 in 1913
> 35 to 1 in 1950
> 44 to 1 in 1973
> 72 to 1 in 1992
> 
> And here's another article:
> LE MONDE DIPLOMATIQUE - November 1998
> The politics of hunger
> by IGNACIO RAMONET 
> 
> Now here's a statistic you might have missed. The total wealth of the world's
> three richest individuals is greater than the combined gross domestic product
> (1) of the 48 poorest countries - a quarter of all the world's states.
> Everybody knows inequality has increased over the last 20 years of unfettered
> ultra-liberalism. But who could have imagined the gap had widened so far? In
> 1960 the income of the 20 % of the world's population living in the richest
> countries was 30 times greater than that of the 20 % in the poorest countries.
> Now we learn that in 1995 it was 82 times greater (2). In over 70 countries,
> per capita income is lower today than it was 20 years ago. Almost three
> billion
> people - half the world's population - live on less than two dollars a day.
> While goods are more abundant than ever before, the number of people without
> shelter, work or enough to eat is constantly growing. Of the 4_ billion people
> giving in developing countries, almost a third have no drinking water. A fifth
> of all children receive an insufficient intake of calories or protein. And two
> billion people - a third of the human race - are suffering from anaemia. 
> Is this the way it has to be? The answer is no. The UN calculates that the
> whole of the world population's basic needs for food, drinking water,
> education
> and medical care could be covered by a levy of less than 4 % on the
> accumulated
> wealth of the 225 largest fortunes. To satisfy all the world's sanitation and
> food requirements would cost only $13 billion, hardly as much as the people of
> the United States and the European Union spend each year on perfume. 
> Next month will see the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration on Human
> Rights, which states that "everyone has the right to a standard of living
> adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including
> food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services". But
> for most of humanity, these rights are increasingly inaccessible. 
> Consider, for example, the right to food. Food is not in short supply. In
> fact,
> food products have never been so abundant. There is enough available to
> provide
> each of the Earth's inhabitants with at least 2,700 calories a day. But
> production alone is not enough. The people who need the food must be able to
> buy it and consume it. And that is precisely the problem. Thirty million
> people
> a year die of hunger. And 800 million suffer from chronic malnutrition. 
> Again, there is nothing inevitable about this. Climatic problems are often
> predictable. When humanitarian organisations like Action Against Hunger (3)
> are
> able to intervene, they can often nip a famine in the bud in a matter of
> weeks.
> And yet hunger continues to decimate whole populations. 
> Why? Because hunger has become a political weapon. In today's world, no famine
> is gratuitous. Hunger is a strategy pursued with unbelievable cynicism by
> governments and military regimes whom the end of the cold war has deprived
> of a
> steady income. Rather than starving the enemy, as Sylvie Brunel points out
> (4),
> they are starving their own populations in order to cash in on media coverage
> and international compassion, an inexhaustible source of money, food and
> political platforms. 
> In Somalia, Sudan, Liberia, North Korea, Burma and Afghanistan, governments
> and
> military leaders are holding innocent people hostage and starving them for
> political ends, sometimes with appalling cruelty. In Sierra Leone, the men of
> ex-Corporal Foday Sankoh's Revolutionary United Front (RUF), in a horrific
> year-long campaign of terror, have been systematically chopping off peasants'
> hands with machetes to prevent them cultivating the land. Climate has become a
> marginal factor in major famines. It is man who is starving man. Amartya Sen,
> the winner of this year's Nobel prize for economics, is renowned for showing
> how government policies can cause famine even when food is abundant. On
> several
> occasions, he has stressed "the remarkable fact that, in the terrible history
> of famines in the world, no substantial famine has ever occurred in any
> independent and democratic country with a relatively free
> press (5)". Rejecting the arguments of the neo-liberals, Professor Sen
> contends
> that greater responsibility for the well-being of society must be given,
> not to
> the market, but to the state. A state that must be sensitive to the needs of
> its citizens and, at the same time, concerned with human development
> throughout
> the world. 
> 
> Translated by Barry Smerin 
> 
> (1) Overall national production of goods and services. 
> (2) Human Development Report 1998, United Nations Development Programme, New
> York, September 1998. See also Dominique Vidal, "Dans le Sud, développement ou
> régression?", Le Monde diplomatique, October 1998. 
> (3) UK office: 1, Catton Street, London WC1R 4AB, email aahuk@gn.apc.org; US
> office: 875 avenue of the Americas, Suite 1905, New York NY 10001, email
> jfvidal@aah.usa.org 
> (4) See Sylvie Brunel and Jean-Luc Bodin, Géopolitique de la faim. Quand la
> faim
> est une arme, (annual report by Action Against Hunger), PUF, Paris, 1998, 310
> p., 125 F, soon to be available in English as "The Hunger Report". 
> (5) See "Human Rights and Asian Values: What Lee Kuan Yew and Le Peng don't
> understand about Asia", The New Republic, July 14, 1997. 
> 
> ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 1998 Le Monde diplomatique 
> 
> ------------------------------------
> -Corrina Chase
> http://web.mit.edu/corrina/tpool/tidepool.html
> 
