Return-Path: <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Received: from central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id MAA16414; Thu, 11 Apr 2002 12:01:14 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id MAA12746
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu>; Thu, 11 Apr 2002 12:00:43 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from tsuga (TSUGA.MIT.EDU [18.214.0.120])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with SMTP id MAA16938
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu>; Thu, 11 Apr 2002 12:00:43 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200204111600.MAA16938@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>
X-Sender: corrina@hesiod
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0.2 
Date: Thu, 11 Apr 2002 12:04:51 -0400
To: nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu
From: Corrina Chase <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Subject: Fwd: Dr. Strangelove is Alive and Well
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"

>To: peace-discuss@MIT.EDU
>Subject: Dr. Strangelove is Alive and Well
>Date: Thu, 11 Apr 2002 11:51:53 -0400
>From: Brice C Smith <elrond@MIT.EDU>
>
>not even Stanley Kubrick could have thought this up.  Since the leak of the
>Nuclear Posture Review, Britain and Pakistan have threatened to use their
>nuclear weapons in the right situation, and even Japan has "warned" China
>that it may build thousands of nuclear warheads if it feels threatened.  Not
>to mention the fact that the US has cut arms control money to Russia claiming
>that Russia is not committed to disarmmament and just yesterday Washington 
>accussed China of seaking to militerizing space.  i am not really sure
what is 
>going to come next, but even i wasn't expecting this...
>
>----------------------
>Nuclear-Tipped Interceptors Studied 
>Rumsfeld Revives Rejected Missile Defense Concept 
>
>By Bradley Graham
>Washington Post Staff Writer
>Thursday, April 11, 2002; Page A02 
>
>Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld has opened the door to 
>the possible use of nuclear-tipped interceptors in a national 
>missile defense system, reviving an idea that U.S. authorities 
>rejected nearly three decades ago as technically problematic 
>and politically unacceptable.
>
>William Schneider Jr., chairman of the Defense Science Board, 
>said yesterday that he had received encouragement from 
>Rumsfeld to begin exploring the idea as part of an upcoming 
>study of alternative approaches to intercepting enemy 
>missiles.
>
>"We've talked about it as something that he's interested in 
>looking at," Schneider said in an interview.
>
>The Pentagon experimented with nuclear-armed interceptors in 
>the 1950s and 1960s and, for a short time in the mid-1970s, 
>deployed an anti-missile system that relied on them. But the 
>notion of nuclear explosions going off high overhead to block 
>incoming missiles proved unsettling for many people. And the 
>prospect that ionized clouds and electromagnetic shock waves 
>associated with the explosions could end up blinding radar on 
>the ground and scrambling electronic equipment eventually 
>helped kill the plan.
>
>Since then, defense officials have focused on developing 
>interceptors to destroy targets without the need for 
>explosives, relying instead on the force of direct impact, a 
>concept known as "hit to kill."
>
>Driving the new interest in arming interceptors with nuclear 
>devices is the problem of dealing with decoys and other 
>measures that an enemy might use to confuse an interceptor, 
>Schneider said.
>
>The hit-to-kill approach depends on interceptors picking out 
>the real enemy targets and homing in on them. By contrast, 
>nuclear-armed interceptors need not distinguish actual targets 
>from clusters of decoys but could rely on explosive power or 
>radiation to wipe out everything in the vicinity.
>
>One other arguable advantage of nuclear interceptors, 
>Schneider suggested, is their potential for ensuring 
>destruction of missile-borne biological warfare agents such as 
>anthrax.
>
>President Bush has made clear his interest in pursuing 
>technological solutions to missile defense, removing long-
>standing constraints by deciding last December to withdraw the 
>United States from the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty with 
>Moscow.
>
>The Pentagon has embarked on experimental anti-missile 
>programs, including land- and sea-based interceptors as well 
>as airborne lasers and space-based weapons, with the hope of 
>having at least a rudimentary capability in place by fall 
>2004. But until now, defense officials had shied away from the 
>nuclear option.
>
>An extensive Pentagon review of missile defense alternatives 
>undertaken in the first months of the Bush administration 
>raised the possibility of nuclear-tipped interceptors, 
>according to two officials familiar with the review. But the 
>idea failed to make the list of
>programs worth funding.
>
>Its return comes in the context of other recent signs of the 
>administration's general readiness to consider broader uses of 
>nuclear weapons. A Pentagon review of U.S. nuclear policy, 
>concluded late last year, put new emphasis on possible nuclear 
>strikes against Third World adversaries and backed development 
>of low-yield nuclear bombs to hit hardened or deeply buried 
>targets.
>
>Russia, which built a missile defense system around Moscow in 
>the 1960s that survives to this day, relied from the start on 
>nuclear-armed interceptors. Although U.S. defense experts 
>regard the Russian system as anachronistic, Russian military 
>officials worry that the United States will eventually adopt 
>the nuclear approach, according to Pavel Podvig, editor of an 
>authoritative book about Russian strategic nuclear forces 
>published last year by the Center for Arms Control Studies in 
>Moscow.
>
>"They believe strongly that you cannot get an effective 
>missile defense system using hit-to-kill," Podvig said.
>
>The Defense Science Board, set up in the 1950s, is a senior 
>advisory body that reports to the secretary of defense on 
>technological, operational and managerial matters. One of its 
>task forces already is looking at some aspects of missile 
>defense, including command and control systems, international 
>cooperation and countermeasures such as decoys. Schneider said 
>he plans to initiate the review of nuclear interceptors and 
>other alternatives to hit-to-kill after the task force 
>completes its study this summer.
>
>"The issue hasn't been looked at for about 30 years," said 
>Schneider, a consultant and undersecretary of state for 
>security assistance under President Ronald Reagan. "The last 
>test involved a four-megaton device on a Spartan interceptor 
>in 1971."
>
>Richard L. Garwin, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign 
>Relations and prominent missile defense skeptic, said nuclear 
>interceptors still pose several significant technical 
>problems.
>
>"When you actually look at the question, you find that it 
>takes a very large warhead -- more than a megaton -- to 
>destroy anthrax spores in bomblets that may be spread over a 
>distance of five kilometers or more," he said.
>
>"Worse, there are hundreds of civilian satellites as well as 
>many U.S. military satellites vital to our national security 
>that would be imperiled by nuclear explosions. And there are 
>electromagnetic pulse vulnerabilities in an advanced society 
>such as ours that would occur to any point within line-of-
>sight of the nuclear explosions."
>
>
>----
>Generally speaking things have gone about as far as they can possibly go when
>things have got about as bad as they can reasonably get
>        - Tom Stoppard
> 
------------------------------------
-Corrina Chase
http://web.mit.edu/corrina/tpool/tidepool.html


