Return-Path: <keithw@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id VAA13158; Tue, 16 Apr 2002 21:36:47 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (MANAWATU-MAIL-CENTRE.MIT.EDU [18.7.7.71])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id VAA26056;
	Tue, 16 Apr 2002 21:36:15 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from multics.mit.edu (MULTICS.MIT.EDU [18.187.1.73])
	by manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id VAA08061;
	Tue, 16 Apr 2002 21:36:14 -0400 (EDT)
Received: (from keithw@localhost) by multics.mit.edu (8.9.3)
	id VAA02806; Tue, 16 Apr 2002 21:36:14 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200204170136.VAA02806@multics.mit.edu>
To: lmf@MIT.EDU
cc: keithw@MIT.EDU
Subject: Minutes of the Reunion, 7 Avril 2002
Date: Tue, 16 Apr 2002 21:36:14 -0400
From: Keith Winstein <keithw@MIT.EDU>

Here are the minutes of the LMF Reunion, 7 Avril 2002. In attendence
were Josh, Morgan, Marissa, Nai, Shaunna, Elina, David, Miriam,
Austin, Mary, Chloe, Sangha, Adrian, Annie, Carrie, Keith, Radu,
Molly, Natalia, Mikael, Michael, Manuel, Megan, Adora, Susan (at
start) + Marc + Chris + Dina + Diana + Paula.

25/33 = 76% at start, 30/33 = 91% at peak.

Jerrad Pierce (belg4mit) was in attendence at the beginning of the meeting.

David carried a proxy vote for Dina, who was tutoring.

Meeting opened at 18h40 by Morgan.

President:

Mary: Close meeting to members?
Jerrad: Here to talk about housing.
Mary: We know nothing yet.

(Meeting closed to members.)

Morgan: CPW, merci. Senior brunch.

Dates: 18 Mai (samedi), 17 Mai (vendredi) (no Adora), 16 Mai neight (jeudi).
Debate.

Selected: 18 Mai, 11h00.

Morgan: Nouveau president responsable.

Adrian: Propose change in guidelines.
Keith reads change. Allow social members for offices other than president
and vice-president.

David: second.

Chloe: Think food-steward also must be resident.
Megan: Propose to add food-steward.
(friendly)

Natalia: Propose to add rush chair.
(not friendly)

-Discussion-

Molly: Point of rush is to live in house.
David: Maybe couldn't get in?
Mary: Chair should live in house, and be extremely aware.
Marissa; Agree.
Sangha: Agree. Could become lame. Not sleepign here, not in 2 a.m.
activities.
Mary: Must live here during rush at least.

Discussion closed.

Vote on rush chair amendment.

Yes: 21
No: 2 + 1 proxy
Abs: 0

Motion passes. Rush chair added to list of must-be-resident officers
in Adrian amendment.

Keith: Propose to add NH Rep to list.
(friendly)

21h00

Molly: List?
Keith reads list.

Chloe: Treasurer should be resident. Envelope, sheets, etc.
Adrian: I only collect once a week.
Chloe: Sysco order, $400 check could get fast if Tresorier is a
resident. Otherwise pain.
Adrian: Social members are members, spend time here.
Chloe: Look at existing social members. Not here enough.
Adrian: President can sign checks too.

Sangha: Propose to add Tresorier.
(not friendly)

Dave: Electorate should decide on a per-vote basis.
They will know where candidates will live.
Molly: I trust members to vote well.
Natalia: For quick questions, important to have around.
Miriam: We could have a social member tresorier if they had
already been a social member, but I wouldn't want to walk across
campus to put up a sign.
Mary: Freshmen lose time after first year.
Josh: Tresurer's responsibility to make people pay.

(Discussion closed)

Vote by secret paper ballot.

Yes: 17
No: 8
Abs: 1
Motion passes. Tresorier added to list which must be resident officer.

21h17

Susan: Propose add education, soirees, environment.
(not friendly)
Megan: Second.

Susan: Education, good to be here to encourage French speaking. Socials
need to know everyone. Environment: Plants, etc.

Marissa: Should vote on each separately.

Natalia: Amendment to split in three.
Susan: (friendly)

(Discussion closed)

Education:

Yes: 12
No: 8
Abs: 5
Motion passes. Education minister added to list of resident required officers.

Social:

Mary: Don't see any reason.
Susan: Social chairs must know personalities so they can organize
activities.

Molly: We are _social_ members. I don't think a social member would run
if they didn't think they know the house.

Morgan: Nothing being taken away.
Keith: All of these are amendments to one big Adrian motion.

Mary: Some of our most social members are social members.

If social chairs do bad job, life goes on. Not so with food steward.

(discussion closed)

Social:

Oui: 2
Non: 18
Abs: 6
Motion failed.

Environment:

Mary: Environment chair is responsible for posters, Curt emails.
David: Description?
Keith reads.

Sangha: I think we should be offended that we don't trust ourselves
to vote properly in the future.

(close discussion)

Oui: 5
Non: 12
Abs: 9
Motion fails.

Natalia: Amendment to invert list (to amend guidelines so that some
can be social, rather than to allow all to be social except for growing
list of exceptions).
(friendly)

(close discussion)

By 2/3 show of hands, to amend guidelines to allow secretary, athletic
chair, social chair, and environment chair to be social members.

Oui: 20
Non: 2
Abs: 5
Amendment to guidelines passes.

21h44

Adrian for social membership.

Adrian: LMF is really cool, I'd like to continue to be a member.
Q: How long will live at MIT?
A: At least fall semester.

(Adrian leaves)
(discussion off the record)

Motion to table matter of Adrian's social membership until later.
Yes: 8
No: 18
Abs: 4
Motion fails.

(discussion off the record)

Motion to close discussion
Yes: 19
No: 5
Abs: 2
Discussion closed.

Vote on 'whether we know Adrian' suspended by white ballot.

Vote on Adrian's social membership, by 2/3 secret ballot.

(by custom, the vote totals do not appear in the e-mailed minutes)

2/3 majority not achieved, social membership vote fails.

22h45

Recess.

23h06

Elections

President:

Nai: Decline
Girls' Triple: Decline
Elicia: Ineligable.
Miriam: Accept, but might be gone second semester.
Morgan: Decline
Radu: Accept
Mary: Decline, but willing to be interim
Keith: Decline
Josh: Decline
Austin: Decline
Radu + Josh: Decline

Candidate speeches

Miriam: Possible gone 2nd term. Kitchen would be a lot cleaner,
a lot more French spoken on my regime. I was happy to work on T-shirts,
videos.

David: How would you deal with a problem?

Miriam: Talk with involved parties, maybe Essigmans.

23h16

Radu: Hope to have time next year. Seems like constant issues, relationships
carried away, this is a small community. I'd try not to let things blow up.
LMF is a great community.

Re: David's question (How would you deal with a problem?)

Radu: I've lived in a small house before with gossip. The President
should make sure things run smoothly, talk with people involved, then
higher authority

David: How do you make judgement calls?

Miriam: Talk with lots of people in house. House can't be babysitter.
Radu: Mediation, people take care of themselves.

Keith: Radu, more French in LMF?
Radu: Would support Ministers of Education in that.

23h26

(discussion without candidates off record)

23h37 Vote by secret ballot

Miriam: 21
Radu: 5
Abs: 3

Miriam is new President.

Vice-President

Mary: Accept
Josh: Decline
Morgan: Decline
Carrie: Accept
Shaunna: Accept
Radu: Decline

Candidate speeches

23h46 Shaunna: Don't have experience, Mary was helpful. Want to be like
her.

Carrie: Want to get really involved. I love it here.

Mary: Was nice to be VP. Vote experience. Have been VP under 3 different
Presidents. Would not make great President. Know how to figure out
what needs to be done. Keep getting in more situations.

23h49 Dina: Hosing?

Mary: Most hosing part is April or summer. Hope to be in Boston for summer.

Shaunna: On pass / no record.
Carrie: Ditto.

Keith: Mary, would you take an apprentice?
Mary: Sure.

[Secretary's note: The guidelines specify that "Officer elections
require simple majority votes by secret ballot." (Section 11.3.2) This
procedure was not following during the meeting, because of secretarial
error. The secretariat apologies.]

Vote by hands:

Shaunna: 8
Carrie: 5
Mary: 10
Abs: 1

Runoff

Shaunna: 13
Mary: 9
Abs: 5

Shaunna is new VP.

00h03 Tresorier

Nai: Not here
Marissa: Not here
Josh: Accept
Keith: Decline
Diana: Accept

Candidate speeches

Josh: I like the house. I'd like to do something for the house.
Diana: I don't cook, so this would be a good way to serve. Would not also
be food steward. I can type.

Keith: Enforcement? What if can't pay?

Josh: Follow protocols. Pay in installments.
Diana: Ditto.

Josh: 16
Diana: 4
Abs: 5

Josh is new Tresorier.

0h11 Aliments

Diana + Natalia: Decline
Diana + Morgan: Accept
Morgan: Decline

[vote]

Diana + Morgan are new food stewards.

00h12 Secretary

Keith: Accept
Carrie: Decline
Mary: Accept
Annie: Accept

Keith: Woudl serve same as before.
Mary: Like to still do something. Neat handwriting.
Annie: Like participating in LMF.
Annie: Planning to take French next term or summer.

Keith: 13
Mary: 5
Annie: 1
Abs: 2

Keith remains Secretary.

00h16 Sports

Carrie: Decline
Marissa: Decline
Radu: Decline
Chloe: Decline
Morgan: Decline
Annie: Accept

[vote]

Annie is new sports chair.

00h20 Rush

Morgan: Description in guidelines inaccurate.

Girls' Triple: Nai not here.
Carrie + Marissa: Decline
Carrie + Marissa + Shaunna: Accept
Radu: Accept

Shaunna: Want to help frosh.
Radu: Here over summer.

C+M+S: 17
Radu: 5
Abs: 1

Carrie, Marissa and Shaunna are new Rush chairs.

00h27 Soirees

Marissa: Decline
Radu: Decline
Annie: Decline
Radu + Annie: Accept

Radu: More parties.
Annie: More parties.
Radu: More outdoors.

[vote]

Radu and Annie are new social chairs.

00h30 Education

Josh + Austin: Decline
Josh, Austin and Radu: Decline

[vote]

Josh, Austin and Radu are new Ministres de l'Education.

00h31 Environment

Mikael: Not here
Dina: Decline
Carrie: Decline
Dina + Carrie: Accept

Keith: Are you sure you know what you're getting into?
Dina + Carrie: Yes.

[vote]

Dina and Carrie are new environment chairs.

00h33 New House representative

Morgan: Accept.
Nai: Not here

[vote]

Morgan is new New House representative.

------

Officer reports

Keith [Education]: Will not be buying Canard, too difficult.
Soirees: Maybe forgo cabin, semi-formal vote will be over email.

Morgan: Thank you all.

Adjourned at 00h37

