Return-Path: <cana@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id KAA15823; Tue, 30 Apr 2002 10:33:31 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (MANAWATU-MAIL-CENTRE.MIT.EDU [18.7.7.71])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id KAA15813
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 30 Apr 2002 10:32:31 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from kinki-sharyo.mit.edu (KINKI-SHARYO-BAY13.MIT.EDU [18.101.1.185])
	by manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id KAA09575
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 30 Apr 2002 10:32:29 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from localhost (cana@localhost) by kinki-sharyo.mit.edu (8.9.3) with ESMTP
	id KAA13329; Tue, 30 Apr 2002 10:32:29 -0400
Date: Tue, 30 Apr 2002 10:32:29 -0400 (EDT)
From: Cana Lynn McCoy <cana@MIT.EDU>
To: <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>
Subject: This mail server concept is part of the patriarchy
Message-ID: <Pine.LNX.4.30L.0204301030300.12899-100000@kinki-sharyo.mit.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII



Minutes of the SIPB Meeting of 04/29/2002

The meeting was called to order at 17:30 by tibbetts.

In attendance were
	Voting members: cana tibbetts aletta aatharuv golem alex_c
		arolfe alien kolya | nim
	Associate members: hartmans mwhitson belmonte jhawk fyfer yak
		sly deberg ingolia | marc
	Non-voting members:
	Prospectives: rax jtu ike jenselby kareid
	Guests:

Treasurer's Report:
	nim: Before the vmware allocation last week, we had $9800.
		I'd be comfortable with SIPB allocation between $7000
		and $8000 more.  I would be happier if all big-ticket
		allocations happened by next meeting.  Please please
		please get it done by next meeting.  Really.

Chairman's Report:

Office Report:
	golem: For anyone not yet aware, I'm going to attempt to have
		SIPB buy cool things.  Digital things.  Move to
		allocate to buy a PIC programmer.  There's an educational
		discount, but I'm unsure what it is.  So, $250
	<seconded>
	yak: How big is this object?
	golem: <not big hand-gestures>  It has a serial interface, it's
		good for programming microcontrollers.  PICs are good
		for lots of things.
	<white ballot>
	[golem allocation: $250 for PIC programmer]

	nim: $500 for a universal PROM programmer.  It does EEPROMs,
		etc.  It programs all of the chips used in 6.111
		and 6.115.
	yak: What is the overlap with the thing we just allocated for?
	nim: Very little.
	<tibbetts seconds>
	tibbetts: FPGAs?
	nim: Yes.
	tibbetts: Does it fail to program anything I care about?
	nim: No.
	<white ballot>
	[nim allocation: $500 for a universal PROM programmer]

	tibbetts: Straw poll on whether an iMac with DVD-R and a PC
		external DVD-R are dependent on each other?  Lots of
		people think so, ok...
	yak: We recently purchased a Mac that seems to be just fine.
	nim: We are not trying to burn money.  We are trying to
		acquire useful things.
	tibbetts: Move to allocate $550 for an IDE DVD burner, to go
		in some PC.  I will attempt to ascertain that the A04
		works as well as the A03.
	cana: Are external ones prohibitively expensive?
	tibbetts: The world does not acknowledge their existence - where
		the world equals Linux.
	yak: There are external firewire ones, but support is almost
		nonexistent.
	belmonte: Last time this was brought up, someone (I think
		keithw) said there were issues with reading DVDs burnt
		on some other drive.
	hartmans: It's less true now.
	yak: Is this DVD-R, RW...?
	tibbetts: This is a DVD-R and a DVD-RW.  Notably not a DVD+RW.
	<white ballot>
	[tibbetts allocation: $550 for an IDE DVD burner]

	mwhitson: Does the SIPB currently have any working zip drives
		identical to the ones in the cluster?
	hartmans: Maybe USB ones would be less ghetto...
	aatharuv: I move that we allocate $300 to purchase two USB 250MB
		zip drives.
	<seconded>
	<white ballot>
	[aatharuv allocation: $300 for two USB 250MB zip drives]

	cana: Straw poll of people who think having 2 Macs, one for
		development use, is a good thing?  <roughly 10>
	hartmans: I don't think there's a point, but an iMac would be
		really useful for other segments of the population.
	rax: If you wanted a development platform, would an older iMac
		be sufficient?  If SIPB buys a iMac rackmount
	kolya: One of the features of having two Macs is that the
		standalone kernel debugger is not as good as Net GDB.
	cana: I move that we allocate to buy a high-end DVD-R
		SuperDrive iMac.
	jhawk: Friendly amendment to add $200 for DVD Studio Pro.
	cana: Sure.
	deberg: Photoshop?  big monitor.
	tibbetts: Can you plug in an external monitor?
	cana: I don't think so.
	<seconded>
	nim: A similar studly G4 would be at least 1,000 more.
	deberg: Ok.
	<$2300 for an iMac: 11-1-6>
	[cana allocation: $2300 for iMac w/SuperDrive + DVD Studio Pro]

	golem: It's been realized that the mythical thornhump upgrade
		won't come out of the server budget - how about the
		office budget?  Move to allocate $1200.
	jhawk: Remind the office what thornhump does.
	golem: Generic crash and burn server.  It does not serve foo,
		it serves broken foo.
	hartmans: You should consider what OS you need.
	tibbetts: The vmware machine can be used for some of these
		things, but not if you want to test things on
		Solaris.  I think the machine should run Solaris.
	yak: How is this better than thornhump?
	golem: It's not entirely clear to me whether steve-dallas will
		be suitable for my purposes.  It hasn't in the past,
		but this may be going to change.
	<$1200 to upgrade thornhump: 4-2-12>
	<apparently that passes>
	[golem allocation: $1200 for thornhump replacement]

	jhawk: My videotape of Revolution OS didn't show up yet.

	tibbetts: So we decided to buy a DVD burner, and an iMac with a
		DVD-R.  Move to spend $300 on a spindle of DVDs.
	jhawk: I'd feel more comfortable if we figured out how we were
		going to disburse them.
	nim: Me too.
	golem: I think we should just buy them.  Something sane will
		happen.
	nim: I don't have that much faith.
	yak: If we buy them, something lame will happen.
	golem: If we don't buy them, something more lame will happen.
	hartmans: Users should be encouraged to buy their own media.
	nim: As someone who is experienced collecting money from a
		student group, if SIPB is willing to accept some
		looseness in how this works, it won't be too much
		work.  It will be non-zero work, though.
	jhawk: It's good to hear that Nick will be here at our times.
		It's enough to here that you want to charge people for
		it.  I think you should try to get Cyrus to deal.
	marc: I don't have a clue how fast these will be used.  I
		think it's reasonable to buy the first batch of 50,
		and see how fast they disappear.
	hartmans: How about this - before we give them away, we make
		sure the users have more than a CD's worth of data.
	<8 in favor of giving them away, 8 in favor of selling them,
	1 abstained>
	golem: Even if we didn't give them away, it's still useful to
		have them around.
	jhawk: I think it's clear that we could go either way on
		this.  Richard, you should just pick one.
	tibbetts: We should just give them away, but people need to
		use them here.
	sly: How do we expect people to get their data over here?  Our
		quotas are small?
	tibbetts: ftp server?
	sly: The network is slow.
	jhawk: Move to buy a new tape drive!
	tibbetts: Motion ignored.
	jhawk: There may be some interaction with the media center
		here, since they have some better tools for this?
	marc: What, awls?
	belmonte: Friendly amendment to substitute the word burn for
		the word use in your proposal.
	<10-0-5>
	[tibbetts allocation: $300 for DVD writable media]

	marc: Have chairs been mentioned at all?
	tibbetts: No.
	sly: Talk to Jonathon, and talk about it next week.

Office Cleaning Report:
	ingolia: The fish has been broken.  I'll fix it in the next
		day or two.

MIT Computing Report:
	sly: We're having our last town hall meeting for resnet.
		We're hoping to get some administrative types there.
		We're also hoping to get some students.  It's being
		held at Talbot lounge 6pm on Thursday.
	marc: Are you having free food? <no>  We should get them food!
	aatharuv: Move that SIPB spends $100 on pizza for the resnet
		meeting.
	golem: This is possibly the most FTGOS thing that's been moved
		at this meeting!
	yak: Would it be ok is I amended +$100 for Grey Goose?
	<laughter>
	nim: The treasurer would like to point out that we cannot buy
		alcohol on the office budget.
	<seconded>
	<white ballot>
	sly: Is someone going to deal?
	nim: I will.
	[nim allocation: $100 for food-based motivation for resnet meeting]

	hartmans: Kerberos 1.2.5 is about to be released.  Apparently
		the most common way to get kerberos outside of the US
		is to pull it out of debian.  It would be nice if
		someone fixed that, because 1.2.5 won't be in debian
		anytime soon.

	hartmans: We've been saturating our outbound net connection.
	sly: One of the routers was misconfigued to send some of the
		nox traffic out the commodity interface.  Now, it's
		doing the right thing.

Computer Services:
	kolya: Bloom-beacon is now a 280R and at some point it peaked
		its ethernet interface at 95MB outgoing.

	tibbetts: steve-dallas is down.  vmware sales people suck,
		alot.
	golem: So, do you like vmware sales people?
	tibbetts: No.

SIPB Backup Report:

Publications Report:
	golem: Why did iAthena cost $97?
	tibbetts: No one knows.
	rax: iAthena, we should do that.  People should bug the people
		who haven't been doing it.

Orientation Report:
	aletta: Jen Tu wanted to run some sort of classes at the
		beginning of term, not during orientation, for
		students who have some background in unix, but not the
		Athena environment - if there's no minicourse on that.
	sly: There isn't.
	golem: Does she know what kind of help she needs?  <no>  We
		should find out.

	arolfe: The summer frosh mailing is due the third week of may.
	tibbetts: Are you still in charge of that?
	arolfe: Yeah

IAP Report:
	alien: The IAP sucker is looking for a deputy sucker.  Talk to
		me!
	marc: You don't need to be a member.

CokeComm Report:

Sucks:
	tibbetts: vmware sale people!
	tibbetts: East Campus network!
	golem: Emacs 21!

Other:
	sly: There's a new virus out, called Klez.  It spreads on
		Windows shares, and may be helping hose the dorm
		networks right now.  If you have publicly-writable
		Windows shares, you should check them and make sure
		they aren't being used for this.

	hartmans: There might be this Debian release on Wednesday.  It
		will hopefully hose our network some.

	golem: Apparently LCS and AI Lab are considering merging.  No
		one knows what this means at all.  Maybe it means that
		the two wireless networks will stop fighting for my
		card.

	yak: Post-meeting key signing party.

	deberg: We should have a contest for writing cool software,
		and win lots of valuable prizes.
	tibbetts: Possibly $2400 of valuable prizes?

Other Other:
	fyfer: I'm really offended by the new emacs.

	jhawk: Compressed air is cool.

	tibbetts: Aletta is back.
	aletta: I'm tan.

	jhawk: Cat now has an auto-noun-poetry page.  It uses images
		from the google images search engine.
		http://web.mit.edu/cat/www/NP/autoNP/

	hartmans: Having a mail server that isn't MIT's is cool.
	rax: I think this mail server concept is part of the patriarchy

The meeting was adjourned at 20:23.

	Minutes taken and submitted by cana.

