Return-Path: <maryr@MIT.EDU>
Received: from central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id BAA02452; Mon, 24 Sep 2001 01:14:53 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (MANAWATU-MAIL-CENTRE.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.85])
	by central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id BAA04041;
	Mon, 24 Sep 2001 01:14:53 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from scaryr.mit.edu (SCARYR.MIT.EDU [18.241.0.139])
	by manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id BAA13278;
	Mon, 24 Sep 2001 01:14:52 -0400 (EDT)
Received: (from maryr@localhost) by scaryr.mit.edu (8.9.3)
	id BAA04422; Mon, 24 Sep 2001 01:14:51 -0400
Message-Id: <200109240514.BAA04422@scaryr.mit.edu>
To: lmf@MIT.EDU
cc: maryr@MIT.EDU
Subject: Duty Implementation Policies
Date: Mon, 24 Sep 2001 01:14:51 -0400
From: Mary Ross <maryr@MIT.EDU>

Several of you have been asking about, "What happens if I don't pay my
housebill?" or, "What happens if I don't show up for cooking / do my
grand nettoyages?"

Of course, the right answer in all these circumstances is to make
arrangements beforehand. In the past, the treasurer has made payment
plans for people unable to pay all their housebill at once, and with
regards to cooking or grand nettoyages, it's easy to find somebody
to substitute with. So no big deal.

If you're just lazy, though, you should know that the house has had to
deal with problems from chronic nonpayment of housebills, and
nonfulfillment of cooking and nettoyages duties. Last year, the problems
got so bad that we amended the guidelines to allow for Duty
Implementation Policies, in order to discourage the sorts of maladies
that occur when we have chronic non-compliance.

The attached document describes the Implementation Policies currently in
effect, affectionately known as the "Enforcement Protocols". This
document is available in PDF format at:

http://web.mit.edu/lmf/www/enforcement.pdf

The executive summary is that if you do not pay your housebill,
show up for cooking, or do your grand nettoyage, we have a system
in place involving fines and housing lottery consequences.

Your loyal servants,
The French House Officers

-----------------------------------------------------------------

	La Maison Francaise Enforcement Protocols
		  As of July 31, 2001

This document outlines the duty implementation policies in force as of
July 31, 2001 in La Maison Francaise. Section 4.5 of La Maison Francaise
Rules and Guidelines authorizes the institution of duty implementation
policies to discourage delinquency in the payment of housebills and to
encourage fulfillment of cooking and nettoyage duties. The specific
implementation policies currently in effect are known as the Enforcement
Protocols A-C.

_History_

In April 2001, after public debate about methods to increase levels of
compliance with house requirements as well as general harmony, Dina
Feith authored and publicly posted a draft entitled "Enforcement
Protocols" proposing to address these and related issues. After two
revisions motivated by comments submitted by French House members, Dina
put forth a document at the May 6 house meeting detailing policies to
address and decrease the problems associated with (A) non-payment of
housebills, (B) non-fulfillment of cooking duties and (C) nettoyage
duties, (D) destruction and damage of house and member property, (E1)
noise and (E2) parties, and (F) non-fulfillment of duties assigned to
house officers. After an hour of debate in English, the present members
voted 13-2-0 to institute a system of "strikes" with associated
non-monetary and monetary penalties, amended versions of Protocols A--C
and "to authorize appropriate guideline modifications to put these
policies into effect."

_Guidelines_

The following sections in the Rules and Guidelines reference
the institution of duty implementation policies:

Sec. 4.5 (Authorization)

Duties: Implementation Policies

The house may institute duty implementation policies to discourage
delinquency in the payment of housebills and to encourage fulfillment of
cooking and nettoyage duties. Such policies may require the Tresorier to
assess, and Vice-President to record, monetary and non-monetary
penalties, respectively.

Sec. 9.2.1 (Housing priority decrease authorized as non-monetary
penalty)

Housing Policy: Placement in French House: Lottery List

[...] Sometime in April, usually in the week following officer
elections, the Vice-President makes the spring lottery list. [...]
People are randomly ordered within their class. Incoming seniors are
given first priority, followed by juniors, then sophomores. [...]
Notwithstanding the above, a member's priority in the lottery may be
decreased as specified by duty implementation policies. [...]

Sec. 12.3 (Vice-President records non-monetary penalties)

Officers: Vice-President

[...] Record non-monetary penalties specified by duty implementation
policies [...]

Sec. 12.4 (Tresorier assesses monetary penalties)

Officers: Tresorier

[...] Assess monetary penalties specified by duty implementation
policies [...]

_Implementation Policies_

Four duty implementation policies are currently in effect. One general
implementation policy describes the system of "strikes" with
associated non-monetary and monetary penalties. The other three specific
implementation policies are the amended Enforcement Protocols A--C.

Strikes

A "strike" is a non-monetary penalty which may be applied to any member
of the house by a duty implementation policy. The Vice-President will
record strikes. A strike will last only until the end of the academic
year. If at the time of the spring housing lottery a member has at least
three strikes, that member will be placed at the end of the lottery
list. (If more than one member fits this criterion, they will be ordered
by the age of their most recent strike: more recent strikes yield lower
priority.) For each strike in excess of three or, for seniors (who will
not be living in the house the subsequent year) in excess of two, a
member will be fined a monetary penalty of 100 by the Tresorier. If a
member records his or her third strike after the spring housing lottery
but before the end of the academic year, the Vice-President will have
discretion whether to move the member to the end of the lottery list and
re-run the lottery, or to assess a 100 fine. The house may vote to ask
any member with five or more strikes to move out.

Enforcement Protocol A: Housebill payment

If a member fails to pay his or her housebill by the due date without
having established alternate arrangements with the Tresorier, or if a
member fails to comply with a due date established by such alternate
arrangements:

The member will be fined a monetary penalty of 5 for every
two weeks after the due date until payment is rendered or alternate
arrangements established with the Tresorier.

The member will be granted one strike for every month after the
due date until payment is rendered or alternate arrangements
established with the Tresorier.

During period of delinquency (from due date until payment or
establishment of alternate arrangements) member may not eat house
meals or use sign-out items or house supplies.

Enforcement Protocol B: Cooking duty non-fulfillment

If a member fails to show up for cooking or shows up more than thirty
minutes late without finding a substitute or establishing alternate
arrangements with the rest of his or her cooking team:

The member will be fined a monetary penalty of 15 by the
Tresorier.

The present members may, by consensus, decide to grant the
missing or tardy member one strike.

Enforcement Protocol C: Nettoyage duty non-fulfillment

If, by Sunday at 4 p.m. during the assigned week, a member fails to
either complete his or her nettoyage(s) or establish arrangements for a
replacement to do so:

The member will be fined a monetary penalty of 10 by the Tresorier.

The member must, during the following week, either complete the assigned
nettoyage(s) or establish arrangements for a replacement to do so.

If the nettoyage(s) is/are not completed during the
following week, the member will be given one strike.

Abuse of the provision to establish arrangements for a replacement to
complete assigned nettoyages is not encouraged.




