Return-Path: <cana@MIT.EDU>
Received: from central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id JAA03305; Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:45:42 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id JAA17312
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:43:55 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from boeing-vertol.mit.edu (BOEING-VERTOL.MIT.EDU [18.18.2.164])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id JAA27911
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:43:55 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from localhost (cana@localhost) by boeing-vertol.mit.edu (8.9.3) with ESMTP
	id JAA12915; Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:43:55 -0400
Date: Tue, 4 Jun 2002 09:43:55 -0400 (EDT)
From: Cana Lynn McCoy <cana@MIT.EDU>
To: <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>
Subject: I don't believe in fairies three times
Message-ID: <Pine.GSO.4.30L.0206032033160.27298-100000@x15-cruise-basselope.mit.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII



Minutes of the SIPB Meeting of 06/3/2002

The meeting was called to order at 19:30 by tibbetts.

In attendance were
	Voting members: cana nim arolfe aatharuv emarcus alex_c jmorzins
		golem tibbetts
	Associate members: tytso jhawk hartmans eisenbud xela dmaze
		yak belmonte ingolia | marc dbj srz
	Non-voting members:
	Prospectives: int18 | jenselby ilai lokie
	Guests:

Treasurer's Report:
	nim: I want to remind people how the Treasurer's drawer works.
		There are four folders in the front.  These are the
		only folders you should interact with.  They are all
		clearly labeled.  Do not put anything or take anything
		from anywhere else in the drawer.  It will greatly
		confuse me.
	tibbetts: Is there still a "to be filed" folder?
	nim: Yes.  You don't put anything in that one. It's not one of
		the first four.
	jhawk: Don't put folders with dumb names on them in the first place.
	nim: I didn't create it.
	jhawk: Still.

	nim: If you have any allocations that you haven't spent, let
		me know ASAP.
	hartmans: Is expensive stuff like the DVD and the iMac done
		yet?
	nim: Yes, they've all cleared SAP.
	tibbetts: Yay SAP.
	nim: No.

	nim: Before anyone tries to buy anything via the Jane interface, you
		must make sure you won't be charged tax, we can't buy
		things for which we'll be charged tax.
	cana: Won't Jane deal with that for you?
	nim: Not if the vendor's website has no easy way of doing it.

Chairman's Report:

Office Report:
	jhawk: golem was saying he wanted some headphone extensions.
		I was in favor of this until I heard what he wanted to
		do with them.
	tibbetts: What does he want to do with them?
	golem: I talked to the people who have some extras, and I'll
		get 'em from them.

	alex_c: The missing y-mouse showed up.  I had stolen it.

	tibbetts: Move to spend $3000 on an HP8150dn printer to
		replace meadow.  It is less deep, but somewhat
		taller.  Any SIPB members under four feet will have
		trouble reaching it.
	<seconded>
	xela: Was this picked because it's an IS-approved model
	tibbetts: Yes, and I heard lots of FUD about other brands, and
		having to put them behind a firewall.
	jhawk: Does it need access from both sides?
	tibbetts: No.
	jmorzins: Even if it jams?
	tibbetts: We wouldn't put it that way.  <hand gestures>
	jhawk: Can we get it with any fancy options they don't have in
		the cluster?
	tibbetts: The only option we could get would be the "huge"
		option, which would make it five feet tall.
	belmonte: Can we get something that has the capability to take
		off someone's arm? Because it's always more fun that
		way.
	tibbetts: I was considering printers that could be brought
		together to form Voltron, but we'd have to convince
		hotline to switch the cluster over too.
	<white ballot>
	[tibbetts allocation: $3000 for HP8150dn printer]

	nim: Move to allocate $150 for a Brother plain paper fax
		machine.
	<seconded>
	tibbetts: I don't think we want one of these, because we could
		get a modem and modems are cooler.
	yak: I don't think we should get this because there's a pay
		fax machine downstairs.
	jhawk: It's not good for receiving faxes.
	hartmans: We could get a modem to receive faxes.
	dmaze: A fax machine will have a straightforward interface
		that people will know how to use, that won't break
		when we reconfigure the office.
	tytso: The most important resource in SIPB right now is desk
		space.  Where are we going to put this thing?
	tibbetts: Back there somewhere.
	nim: A fax machine would still work even if a computer didn't
		work.  We are lame about keeping software and computers
		working.
	alex_c: Has anyone asked the PSC/CAC if they'd mind us using
		their faxing ability?
	hartmans: You know, there's these l33t services on the net
		where they'll convert incoming faxes to email.
	<vote:6-11-4, fails>

	tibbetts: I'd like to move to buy a modem.
	aatharuv: PCI modems are often WinModems these days.
	tibbetts: We want an external modem.
	xela: I could donate a 56k modem.
	hartmans: That works with Linux?
	tibbetts: Is it one of those USR grey ones?
	xela: Yeah.
	hartmans: That works with Linux.
	tibbetts: Move to allocate up to $150 to buy an external modem
		(which may be 0 if I get it from Alex).
	<seconded>
	jhawk: I think the logistics of having this electronic fucking
		suck.  As a user of paper faxes, it's...
	<chair makes banging sounds>
	alex_c: We should talk to our W20 neighbors, again.
	<vote: 11-3-7, passes>
	[tibbetts allocation: $150 for an external modem]

	marc: It's going to be summer for the next three or four
		months. That means you should manipulate the
		thermostat with its settings, not with the on/off
		buttons.
	jhawk: It was freezing in here this morning, that's why it was off.
	belmonte: Clearly you should ask people in the office about
		their preferences, before you adjust the thermostat.

	tibbetts: I'd like to allocate for two or three large IDE
		disks - for into pickled, thornhump, and maybe
		multics.
	marc: thornhump and multics require arcane mounting hardware.
	tibbetts: That isn't in the box?
	marc: For one drive.
	tibbetts: It looks like a second would work.
	marc: Not in the one I bought.
	tibbetts: I want to use it to store mp3s to NFS export to the office.
	golem: I think we should lower the marginal cost of storage.
	tibbetts: I guess I don't care about all three.  Move to
		allocate $250 for 120GB drive for pickled.
	<seconded>
	<white ballot>
	[tibbetts allocation: $250 for 120GB drive for pickled]

	tibbetts: Move to allocate $250 for 120GB drive for multics to NFS mount
		to the office for the storage of mp3s.
	belmonte: Whose mp3 would be on this machine?
	tibbetts: Anyone who wants to put them there?  Members?
	belmonte: I guess I'm concerned about the copyright issues.
	tibbetts: There are no copyright issues.
	<laughter>
	alex_c: Are you aware of the company that settled with the
		RIAA for doing exactly this?
	tibbetts: No.
	hartmans: There was some discussion of this over zephyr, and
		what I think is a reasonable (although we should check
		for legal precedent) is explicitly having a policy
		that individual people considering using the data on
		the system are expected to evaluate the legal issues
		and only use it according to fair use from a copyright
		standpoint.
	marc: Why not just give people space in the SIPB AFS cell for
		mp3s?
	tibbetts: It's more expensive, needs to be broken up into
		volumes, there are ACL problems, and you need to deal
		with requests though sipb-afsreq.
	xela: Everyone in the discussion on zephyr agreed putting them
		in AFS was just the wrong thing:
	golem: All those things about AFS are true.  Historically,
		sipb-afsreq has been cagey about giving out quota.
		Secondly, Sam's idea is terrible.  You can either do
		complete control of your users, or no control of your
		users.  We don't want to do complete control of our
		users.
	xela: I would amend your motion to only say the motion is for
		a disk for multics, with no stated purpose.
	tibbetts: Accepted.
	hartmans: I think that (having no stated policy) is what I
		said.  I resent Chris' implication about sipb-afsreq.
	marc: I think we should table the motion until we know if we
		actually can mount the hard drive in the machine.
	tibbetts: How about I just raise the allocation by $100, and
		if that's not enough, we yell at Sun.
	<vote: 7-5-6, passes>
	[tibbetts allocation: $350 for a 120GB drive for multics]

	tibbetts: lnitp is there, takes up desk space, and gets
		decreasing amounts of love.  I think we should get a
		second video card for pickled, and put a monitor (and
		someday a flat-panel) on it, and run xcluster there.
		Move $100 for a PCI video card.
	<seconded>
	hartmans: Running random services on office heads sucks.
	tibbetts: Is there configuration to do?
	hartmans: Yes.  Would you be willing to write a .private file that
		does the right thing?
	yak: If he's not, I am.
	jhawk: I don't think it takes up too much space, and works
		better on its own.
	tibbetts: I think it takes about the same amount of space as
		your laptop and other shit, and everyone hates that
		too.
	marc: Friendly amendment that it have a DVI port.
	tibbetts: Sure.
	marc: I'm gonna vote for it, but I have this fear that jhawk
		will expand his cruft space.
	yak: No, I think it'll be easier to reclaim the space then,
		since it won't be just a small space between two
		computers.
	<white ballot>
	[tibbetts allocation: $100 for a 2nd video card for pickled]

	golem: I was telling a user about our money problem, and a
		particular user mentioned that we should get wireless
		cards for the office.  And I said, "Great idea!", but
		the last person who suggested it got all shot down, so
		maybe I shouldn't suggest it, but I just did.
	tibbetts: Only if you chain the cards to a desk.
	hartmans: We could resurrect our laptop drops and get back
		into a state where we can actually have places for
		users to plug in.
	jhawk: I would like to agree with Sam, and also if we had
		wireless cards, they'd be registered for MIT DHCP,
		which might makes things easier, but I don't like this
		idea.
	tibbetts: I don't like it either.
	golem: $100 for a wireless card for the office?
	<seconded>
	<vote: 4-8-6, fails>

	xela: ZSR is gone.
	golem: There's a space where ZSR used to be.  It's a happy space.

	aatharuv: We now have USB zip drives on opus and csw.  They should just
		work.

Office Cleaning Report:

MIT Computing Report:
	hartmans: Did I mention warlord's stuff about disconnected
		operation last week?  There was a discussion either
		last week or the week before about a white paper
		presented by wdc about disconnected operation in the
		Athena environment.  This is an interesting topic
		that people should follow, especially people who are
		interested in laptops.  People should read it,
		source-developers is a public discuss meeting.

Computer Services:
	tibbetts: seph and I, which means mostly seph, got rt into a
		state where it accepts passwords and certs, and
		auto-creates users in the MIT realm.
	hartmans: Want!
	tibbetts: You can log in and steal the config.

SIPB Backup Report:
	hartmans: A week ago I mentioned that I was getting worried
		about the zephyrs the SIPB backups were was sending out.  Garry
		explained it to me: We do fulls on Tuesdays and not
		Sundays, and they overflow one tape.  So everything's
		fine.  But there's more data in the SIPB cell than
		there used to be.

Publications Report:

Orientation Report:

IAP Report:

CokeComm Report:
	tibbetts: CokeComm was online today talking about trying to
		get vanilla Coke.
	marc: If you know of a source, tell CokeComm.

Other:

Other Other:
	dbj: Someone managed to get the SCSI driver working on the
		NetBSD/NeXT port.  I'm very happy.

	marc: Like jhawk, many students must have nothing to do,
		because the meeting was drawn out with lots of silly
		comments.

	belmonte: Bye.
	<bye! bye! *sniff*>

	cana: I now have ear-mountable T tokens.


The meeting was adjourned at 20:10.

	Minutes taken and submitted by cana.

