Return-Path: <rax@yiff.mit.edu>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id TAA03404; Tue, 13 Aug 2002 19:11:41 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id TAA24104
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 13 Aug 2002 19:10:40 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from yiff.mit.edu (YIFF.MIT.EDU [18.238.2.156])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id TAA28877
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 13 Aug 2002 19:10:39 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from rax by yiff.mit.edu with local (Exim 3.35 #1 (Debian))
	id 17ekoB-0002OD-00
	for <sipb-minutes@mit.edu>; Tue, 13 Aug 2002 19:10:39 -0400
Date: Tue, 13 Aug 2002 19:10:39 -0400
From: rax <rax@MIT.EDU>
To: sipb-minutes@mit.edu
Subject:  I would have appreciated if this meeting were short.
Message-ID: <20020813231039.GQ30672@yiff.mit.edu>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
User-Agent: Mutt/1.4i
Sender: Rax <rax@yiff.mit.edu>


Minutes of the SIPB Meeting of 08/12/2002


The meeting was called to order at 7:30 by tibbetts.

In attendance were
	Voting members: rax alex_c cfox tibbetts golem | arolfe nim
	Associate members: jhawk kcr deberg xela tytso rjbarbal
		ingolia hartmans dbj marc | jweiss
	Non-voting members:
	Prospectives: kilroi gschmidt jenselby
	Guests:

Treasurer's Report:

	nim: We have fat piles of cash.

Chairman's Report:

	hartmans: Move to repeal the policy that tallies for membership
		elections not go in the mail.
	xela: As the person who caused this policy to come into effect, there's
		a certain amount of embarrassment to go with this
		happening.
	marc: Do you feel that this not being in the minutes softened the blow?
	xela: No.  
	<12-2-2, motion passes>


	jhawk: It would have been nice to satisfy objections before the vote.
	rjbarbal: I think most of the objections were answered in email.

	alex_c: I am going to sponsor rdm@alum.mit.edu for an account based on
		/afs/sipb/admin/text/guest-accounts-policy. I figure
		there will be comments.

	hartmans: First, some people have suggested I am not a current student
		and thus should not comment. If they feel this way they
		should speak up. It is clear that according to that
		policy any SIPB member is entitled to an account. i
		think that that assertion is inconsistent with the
		rationale in the policy and sort of inconsistent with
		what we ought to be doing. According to tat policy, we
		have this ability in order to FTGOS, and the reason that
		SIPB members are entitled to an account is that it will
		allow that to happen. In cases where it does not, I
		think we should not sponsor the account. As such I wish
		to propose a resolution to the board:

		 It is the sense of the SIPB that: 1) All SIPB sponsored
		accounts are sponsored in order to FTGOS, including
		accounts for members. 2) When an account is created for
		a SIPB member, the same information should be provided
		as for a non-member sponsored account. 3) The text of
		the guest accounts policy should be streamlined to make
		member and non-member accounts as similar as
		possible. 4) As a general rule members are presumed to
		be using their existing account to FTGOS.
	jhawk: The person's name is Ronald Mabbitt '79, and that should be in
		the minutes.  
	<kcr seconds>
	cfox: As an EC member alex_c, you have a mandate to FTGOS. How will this
		FTGOS?
	alex_c: It is SIPB's policy.
	cfox: is it one of SIPB's goals to further the policy?
	alex_c: Why is it a stupid policy?
	cfox: Policy aside, does this FTGOS aside from the policy?
	tibbetts: You can decline to respond.
	arolfe: I haven't seen whether he wants to FTGOS or not, which means
		that he falls into the same category as huge numbers of
		other members who may or may not be FTGOSing. And unless
		we are going to monitor them, it seems like we may be
		being sort of arbitrary.
	jhawk: I want to object to Camilla's contention that EC members have to
		always be FTGOSing. He should not have to prove that he
		is FTGOSing any more now than when he is eating a
		sandwich.
	cfox: When he is acting as an EC member- 
	jhawk: I don't believe he is.
	golem: I believe it FTGOSes to keep in touch with crufty members and
		giving him this account does this.
	hartmans: it seems clear to me that he does not want to FTGOS with this
		account; it seems that he wants a free email account
		since mac.com is going away. If he wants to FTGOS, I
		think it is fine to give him an account. It happens to
		be that if it turns out he is lying (lying != being
		incredibly lame) we should dismember him, but that is my
		personal opinion. If someone is not willing to even
		assert that they will FTGOS, there is no reason to give
		them an account.
	marc: Any EC member who acts in accordance with policy should be assumed
		to be FTGOSing unless they are bending the
		policy. Either the policy is wrong or alex is being
		reasonable.
	xela: The assumption is that SIPB members FTGOS. Sam, under your policy
		why shouldn't we review accounts every year?
	hartmans: I agree that the presumption is important and we should make
		it. When someone says "I want a free email account" it
		is hard for me to presume that.
	xela: I assume that if he replies at all, he will have at least some
		intent to FTGOS.
	hartmans: And if he does, I think he should get an account.
	kcr: I think that it is not a big deal to give this guy an account. He
		was kind of peremptory about it, but SIPB members are
		never rude. Then there is camilla asking alex how this
		FTGOSes. Whether alex is presumed to be acting in
		accordance with the laws of SIPB god and man when he is
		an EC member is irrelevant; cfox can certainly ask how
		he is going to FTGOS, and that is a reasonable
		question. The other issue is Sam's sense of SIPB
		question, also reasonable, and not fantastically germane
		to the account. I think Sam's statement probably
		reflects people's reality a little better than policy. I
		think we do want to make the vague assertion that people
		have accounts to FTGOS. If not, what are they for?
	nim: There are 2 issues. The issue of whether we should give him an
		account it the same as should we let cruft keep
		accounts. We seem to be letting cruft keep accounts. I
		think we should give him an account. We should look at
		whether or not this is good later.
	jhawk: Nowhere does the email correspondence discuss mac.com going away,
		much less this as the reason. Maybe there was private
		correspondence.
	hartmans: This was in mail to sipb, not sipb-ec 
	arolfe: I think it is FTGOSing to maintain this, and it is equally
		important for sipb to stay in touch with old members
		as vice versa. It is possible he has been away, has no
		idea what we do, and does not know how to get
		involved. We should give him the opportunity.
	hartmans: I agree, if he is interested and comes forward to say he wants
		to get involved. I think this counts as FTGOSing. I want
		to try to justify this policy change. A lot of times,
		basically I believe it will put us in a much better
		political position if people ask why we have guest
		accounts. We can better justify our actions to ourselves
		and others.
	marc: Up one metalevel, this guy is in the same class as Jeff. It may
		FTGOS to give him an account even if he does not do
		anything directly. There is some chance he will complain
		to Jeff and this will give us fallout.
	alex_c: I apologize for declining to answer before. I was just trying to
		do the right thing. I feel like slamming the door in
		this guys face is a violation of charter. When I learned
		that I would keep my account, it was my understanding I
		would keep it as long as I did nothing idiotic, not that
		i would lose it because of some technological accident
		or upgrade.
	jhawk: Could you clarify how your policy changes the old one?
	hartmans: I am proposing a sense of the SIPB. I believe it would require
		new accounts to be FTGOSing though it would not require
		that for existing accounts and it would not change
		review. It would make the belief that the accounts are
		to FTGOS and not an entitlement clear to external
		parties and holders.
	arolfe: Call the question.
	golem: I object.
	marc: I'd like to move the question.
	tibbetts: You're a bastard.
	tibbetts: All in favor of voting now: 
	<14-1-3, voting now> 
	<7-7-5, sense of SIPB does not pass>

	jhawk: Out of curiosity, I would appreciate a straw poll of voting
		members only.
	rjbarbal: I want to break it down into the four points.
	tibbetts: I like jhawk's version.  
	<4-1-2, nothing happens>
	hartmans: It seems we don't have a consensus on my proposal. Someone
		could move on the account issue.
	tibbetts: I move we don't give him an account unless he comes back with
		a reason.  
	<cfox seconds>
	marc: Is because I want one a reason?
	hartmans: Friendly amendment that if he gets back without claiming to
		FTGOS, he also gets no account.
	tibbetts: No.
	alex_c: Amend to mention that we should tell him this? Never mind.
	dbj: A variation on the resolution might be reasonable. I believe we
		should just offer him the account and tell him we are
		offering it so he can FTGOS, not make it contingent. Can
		I table this until after we contact him?
	hartmans: If you move to table it, alex_c can create the account.
	alex_c: I won't.
	dbj: Move to table this for 3 weeks; if we do not hear from him we
		should pick it up again. Before we make a formal motion
		to actually not give him an account, I want to talk to
		him.  
	<xela seconds>
	jhawk: Wouldn't it make more sense for tibbetts to withdraw his motion?
	jweiss: If you're thinking that hard have the vote.  
	<5-5-7, not tabled>
	jhawk: It strikes me that you are in an extremely untenable position to
		assert that you don't want to create the account when
		you have sent email to him suggesting that he should
		reply to us and then follow that from more email
		suggesting he reply to him before he replies to us.
	rax: You're trying to say we confused him.
	jhawk: Yes.
	tibbetts: I do not plan to send him email, I bet alex_c does.
	xela: This motion puts the SIPB in a value judgment business. The SIPB
		sucks at value judgment.
	hartmans: I don't like this motion, because it seems unclear who
		evaluates the reason or if it can be evaluated.
	tibbetts: It is my vague intent that my reason be evaluated and the EC
		can sort it out.  alex_C Why don't I deal and come back
		next week?
	tibbetts: I withdraw my motion.
	alex_c: I'd like to apologize for not raising these objections when you
		provided an opportunity.
	tibbetts: That's fine, my opportunity was not as good as it could have
		been.

	golem: If SIPB had laser vision, our navels would be charred lumps of
		coal.

Office Report:

	jweiss: I am planning to schedule an outage to upgrade Multics to 9.1
		soon; if you care, talk to me.

	dbj: Unless someone knows we have a SCSI cable, I want to allocate $50
		to buy a 68-50 pin SCSI cable.
	xela: Friendly amendment for $100.
	jhawk: $200 for 2?  
	<jweiss seconds> 
	<white ballot>

	tibbetts: I move to allocate $100 to buy OS X.2.  
	<kcr seconds>
	xela: Have you looked into developer accounts?
	tibbetts: It is under $200, which might give us the OS for free. It is
		not clear it would give us anything else for free.
	dbj: Is $100 enough money?
	tibbetts: Yes.
	<white ballot>
	
	tibbetts: MS office X for Mac. We allocated last year and cana and I
		dropped the ball. How much is it? I have heard $20 to
		a lot. I am going to allocate $500. I am pretty sure
		it is less but we want it.  
	<white ballot>

	tibbetts : I would like a voice modem for the fax thing which we never
		did. $150 for a voice/fax/whizbang everything 56k
		modem. External.
	jweiss: Can you give me the explanation?
	tibbetts: The idea is we allow people to receive faxes on Athena without
		thinking about the problem using UIDs. The minimalist
		idea is that SIPB gets a fax.  
	<white ballot>

	tibbetts: Since Arun is not here, move $1000 for 5 additional IPs for
		the vmware machine?
	jweiss: They cost $192/IP/year.
	hartmans: I'm not sure we need these.
	tibbetts: People currently use laptop addresses in order to conserve
		IPs. There is demand for more.
	dbj: I am sure we need more. I would like there to be addresses free you
		can only use actively at that moment.
	tibbetts: I just started tracking them. Actually, does SIPB have extra
		IPs floating around the office we don't keep track of?
	jweiss: There are probably fewer than 5 unreclaimed office heads. It
		would not be too difficult to do this.
	jhawk: What happened to the tunnel idea? ted-williams.
	tibbetts: It was rejected by ted-williams-maintainers.
	golem: We could use DHCP.
	tibbetts: We should pay for IPs and suck it up.  
	<white ballot>

	tibbetts: How much is a gig DIMM?
	kcr: Like $400?
	tibbetts: PC133, for steve-dallas. Move to allocate $500 for a second
		gigabyte DIMM.  
	<kcr seconds>
	tibbetts: Yes, it is often running out of RAM.  
	<white ballot>

	jhawk: Someone has discovered they can change the cluster map by
		scribbling on our copy on the bulletin board.

	jweiss: Some number of the cooling units in the office are having some
		number of issues. If there is someone around the office
		during business hours, they should report this to
		someone who might be able to fix the problem.

	rax: So, deathtongue is wicked skank. I think we should get a newer
		PC. $1600 for a cluster config intellistation, only
		with DVD and a half a gig of RAM.
	jweiss: Is that not the cluster config? Is that enough for a machine
		and should it include a monitor?
	tibbetts: Yes and no.
	yak: zsr has a half gig.
	jhawk: How much faster would MS Word start?
	kcr: Much.
	tibbetts: I would estimate 4 or 5.
	jhawk: That might be worth it.
	golem: As a suggestion, would it be totally unreasonable to buy some
		sort of sun, and put a dell in its position?
	hartmans: What about zsr?
	tibbetts: They are all laughably slow except maybe zsr.
	jweiss: I would only feel comfortable rotating something into that spot
		if we have another one, and this is only true of the
		GX1.
	jhawk: How much of our budget is this?
	nim: 16/380. Out of what we have left and repeating allocations,
		16/250-300. I anticipate we will run into a similar
		situation as last fiscal year.
	marc: Never mind.  
	<white ballot>

	marc: The machine we are putting Office X on, does it have office?
	hartmans: No.
	marc: Ok.

	jweiss: Move to get rid of the old deathtongue at the discretion of when
		the new one arrives. 
	<white ballot>


	tibbetts: Jonathon. There is this box labeled Gamadrid.
	jweiss: I will deal with that soon.

	kcr: There is a radio-controlled car siting on top of the filing
		cabinet. Whose is it?
	dbj: It lists alien and mwhitson.

	jhawk: We got a new receiver. It works. Someone should hook up the other
		two speakers.

	tibbetts: The USB audio widget still doesn't work because I suck or
		linux sucks. Someone else should look at it.

	Office Cleaning Report:

	xela: The office is a pit.

MIT Computing Report:

	jweiss: The dialups are being upgraded to 9.1. This may lead to
		questions about pine or gnus.

Computer Services:

	hartmans: sipb-debian is sucking, first because our mirror went away
		though that was fixed (thanks Adam). We seem to have
		issues fitting on one CD and thanks to the weekend lost
		we are behind and hosed but I will attempt to deal. Last
		week I was hosed but Antonio and Jen and Arun put in lots
		of work and things are still falling together. I do not
		know about docs; i will talk to Jacquie and find out.

	jhawk: I have not forgotten my attempts to get a UPS into 410T.

	arolfe: Today I started my first adventure with a SCSI hard drive which
		does not love me.

	hartmans: (1) SCSI chickens. (2) Alex and rax are lame, they should talk
		to me later.

	alex_c: Move to allocate $50 for physiotherapy for rax's fingers.
	tibbetts: Is that something they do in Australia?  
	<black ballot>

SIPB Backup Report:

Publications Report:

	tibbetts: Did either alex_c or I deal with latex? 
	alex_c : No; tomorrow.

Orientation Report:

	nim : It's sooner than you think. 

IAP Report:

	xela: It's sooner than you think.

CokeComm Report:


Other:

	nim: The new system MIT has for dealing with money sucks a lot a lot a
		lot a lot a lot I hate them all.

	jhawk: The case against me was dismissed. Now I get to sue.

	arolfe: Every room at Random hall has asbestos, for some reason they
		though mine might not.

	golem: I move we allocate $100 for a mattress so that SIPB can stuff
		money in it.
	hartmans: Friendly amendment to make it FDIC-insured.
	tibbetts: Friendly amendment to make it not sleepable.
	nim: SIPB does not follow the student interface, it has the Jane
		interface which is fine.
	<motion ignored>

	rax: I hate you all.

	tibbetts: Move that it is the sense of the SIPB that we hate rax too.
		Vote by acclimation?
	kcr: Objection.
	tibbetts: Withdrawn. You suck too Karl.

Other Other:

	jweiss: The midnight Bike Ride is next weekend. If you are interested,
		especially if you are a ham, talk to me.

	hartmans: I would have appreciated if this meeting were short.

The meeting was adjourned at 20:26.

	Minutes taken and submitted by rax.
