Return-Path: <scs@eskimo.com>
Received: from pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id TAA12122; Thu, 22 Aug 2002 19:45:00 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from mail.eskimo.com (mail.eskimo.com [204.122.16.4])
	by pacific-carrier-annex.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id TAA02531
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu>; Thu, 22 Aug 2002 19:44:05 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from eskimo.com (scs@eskimo.com [204.122.16.13])
	by mail.eskimo.com (8.9.1a/8.8.8) with ESMTP id QAA03419;
	Thu, 22 Aug 2002 16:44:04 -0700 (PDT)
From: Steve Summit <scs@eskimo.com>
Date: Thu, 22 Aug 2002 19:44:04 -0400
Message-ID: <2002Aug22.1944.scs.0014@eskimo.com>
To: nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu
Subject: Re: AILG alcohol sub-committee proposal
References: <2002Aug21.2346.scs.004@box16.scs.ndip.eskimo.net>
Cc: scs@eskimo.com

Here's a message I just sent to the AILG mailing list.

			*	*	*

From: Steve Summit <scs@eskimo.com>
Date: Thu, 22 Aug 2002 19:22:41 -0400
To: mitailg@mit.edu
Subject: Re: Results of the alcohol sub-committee
Message-Id: <2002Aug21.2346.scs.004@box16.scs.ndip.eskimo.net>
Cc: scs@eskimo.com

I had a chance conversation in the lunchroom in my office
yesterday that got me thinking about rules.  Someone was eating
a pudding cup, and reminiscing about the days when they came in
little aluminum containers, with pop-top lids.  The lid always
came off with a nice layer of pudding on it, which was tempting
to lick off, but tricky, because it was easy to cut your tongue
on the sharp edge of the lid.  In fact, so my co-worker said,
at her elementary school there had actually been an official
rule passed: "No licking pudding off pudding cup lids."

Now, a rule like this *might* be acceptable in an elementary
school setting, but it's still pretty silly.  And obviously no
adult would stand for the imposition of such a rule.

I am not trying to ridicule the proposed hard liquor ban by
comparing it to the pudding cup lid rule, but they do strike
me as being pretty similar: a legal and even enjoyable (though
risky) activity is prohibited for all, just to protect a few
who might hurt themselves.

I do appreciate the seriousness of the alcohol problem, and
I respect the courage of those who have brought it out into
the open and tackled it.  But this proposed rule, noble and
well-intentioned as it is, is wrong, and the fact that it might
nevertheless help does not make it right.  Pragmatism has its
place, but not here.

One of my house's strong traditions is equality.  There's a
whole bunch of things we take (sometimes excessive) pride in
not discriminating on the basis of, but one of them is age:
upperclasslings don't have any special rights that they get to
lord over frosh and sophomores.  So for me to go in as an alum
and say, "even though I can keep liquor in my house and enjoy it,
you can't; I'm an alum and you're not, so there" would feel very,
very wrong.  That's not the way we do things, and if there's an
alcohol problem that needs solving, there has got to be a better
way.

It's been stated that the current problem exists in spite of
the number of rules (at the national, state, city, and various
institutional levels) that have been enacted in an attempt to
control it.  It's been acknowledged that those rules aren't
working, and that we've got to not further the practice of
just passing politically correct rules that aren't respected
and therefore don't accomplish anything.  But I wonder: what
assurance do we have, when it comes right down to it, that the
proposed rule would be any different?  How *do* we imagine we're
going to enforce it?  If we catch undergraduates in our houses
possessing hard liquor, what are the sanctions going to be?  If
there are repeated violations, are we prepared to evict people?
There will be violations, and there will be repeated violations,
so we have to ask: can we imagine looking a 21-year-old
undergraduate in the eye and telling him we're kicking him out of
the house because he's been caught with a bottle of vodka in his
room for the nth and last time?  That's going to be pretty hard.

With that thought in mind, though, I'd like to consider a related
scenario.  The perception is that there's still a problem, that
there's still (for example) serious binge drinking going on, that
we could easily have another Scott Krueger on our hands any day
now.  Is that something we're pretty sure of based on circumstantial
(but ample) evidence?  Or is it something we've seen with our own
eyes?  And if it is something we have seen with our own eyes
(or could see with our own eyes if we went looking for it), I'd
like to ask: isn't there something we can do about it directly?
Like, tell the person or people in question to their faces that
they're overdoing it, and that we'd very much like them to stop?

Someone correctly pointed out that the concept of "teaching
responsible drinking" is legally specious when it comes to
underage would-be drinkers, but alcohol is something we all
have to learn about, and fraternities (unless dry) are involved
enough in alcohol that they're fine venues for this education,
and elders (whether upperclassmen or alums) are fine candidates
for instructors, either as role models or (if the need arises)
as direct interventionists.

Cutting someone off is hard, no question.  It's probably at
least as hard to go up to someone and say, "You've had too much,
I'm cutting you off" as it is to say "you've been caught with
liquor for the nth time, I'm kicking you out."  But if we don't
think we could say the former, how can we sure we could say the
latter?  And if we can pass a policy that presupposes being
able to say the latter, is there perhaps some other policy we
could invent that centered around the ability to say the former?

Bryan correctly observed that none of the critics had suggested
any alternatives.  What I have to offer isn't a concrete proposal
(and it's just my thinking, not a formal position of our house
or house corporation), but I'd like to suggest that we explore
the possibility of attacking this problem not obliquely with
putatively behavior-modifying rules, but rather with up-front
hands-on actual behavior modification.  If we have reason to
believe that there's binge drinking or other forms of substance
abuse going on in our houses that's getting dangerously out of
hand, what if we stride right in there, as the elders we ought to
be allowed to be, and say, "Stop."  Perhaps, if we're sure enough
we'll have to do this but afraid it will come off badly, we can
also explain to our houses beforehand (i.e. at a beginning of
term house meeting, or otherwise well in advance of the party)
that we're going to be doing this if we have to, even if it means
taking bottles out of people's hands, even if it involves opening
a closed door we haven't been invited to open, if we've heard
that things are getting out of hand behind it.  Obviously this
works (so far as I've described it) only when alums are present
at all, but if problems are likely and we're worried abut them,
perhaps we should be stopping by the house more often.

This probably sounds like a laughably naive proposal.  I admit
I'd have a hard time doing these things, in my own house, where
I'm presumably as comfortable and confident and respected as I
can be.  But, naive or not, if we don't think we could do this
sort of thing, I have to ask: WHY NOT?  If we don't imagine we
could confront a situation like this up-front and hands on,
how do we imagine we can be responsible leaders of our houses
(through thick and thin) at all?  If we don't imagine we could
confront a situation like this, how sure can we be that by
sitting around and talking and passing rules, we can make the
problem go away so that we don't have to confront it after all?

Passing the proposed rule against hard liquor would be very hard,
and would require rather a lot of courage.  Intervening directly,
as I'm suggesting, would be even harder, would take much more and
different kinds of courage.  But this leaves me thinking that
passing the rule (hard as that would be to do) is actually
passing the buck, taking the easy way out, dodging the problem
and hoping it will go away by itself.  If this is a hard problem
(and it is), then shouldn't we be tackling it vigorously, relying
on the leadership skills nurtured in those very houses we're now
involved as alumni of?

I'm going to cut this off before it turns into too much of a
goopy pep talk.  But I'd like people to think about the problem
from this angle, and if the perception is that a policy of
hands-on intervention won't work, I'd like to again ask, why not?
Even if it won't work, I think that talking about it will help us
define our leadership role in a way that will guide our thinking
about the other approaches or rules we might pursue.

					Steve Summit '83
					pika housecorp president
					scs@eskimo.com
