Return-Path: <jmathieu@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id VAA03845; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 21:21:37 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (MANAWATU-MAIL-CENTRE.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.85])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id VAA14643
	for <in-house-pikans@MIT.EDU>; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 21:21:36 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from buzzword-bingo.mit.edu (BUZZWORD-BINGO.MIT.EDU [18.7.16.73])
	by manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id VAA16053
	for <in-house-pikans@MIT.EDU>; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 21:21:36 -0400 (EDT)
Received: (from jmathieu@localhost) by buzzword-bingo.mit.edu (8.9.3)
	id VAA04624; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 21:21:35 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200110060121.VAA04624@buzzword-bingo.mit.edu>
To: in-house-pikans@MIT.EDU
Subject: marilee jones letter
Date: Fri, 05 Oct 2001 21:21:35 -0400
From: Johanna L Mathieu <jmathieu@MIT.EDU>

here is that letter everyone has been making a big deal of.  i highly suggest reading it despite the length.  it's pretty disgusting...

johanna

------- Forwarded Message

Return-Path: <ktwass@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id UAA00289; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 20:06:49 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id UAA12216
	for <jmathieu@mit.edu>; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 20:06:50 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from KTWASS (KTWASS.MIT.EDU [18.238.2.190])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with SMTP id UAA22456
	for <jmathieu@mit.edu>; Fri, 5 Oct 2001 20:06:31 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200110060006.UAA22456@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>
X-Sender: ktwass@hesiod (Unverified)
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0.2 
Date: Fri, 05 Oct 2001 20:08:02 -0400
To: jmathieu@mit.edu
From: Katie Wasserman <ktwass@MIT.EDU>
Subject: Fwd: Marilee Jones (Dean of Admissions) on the New Improved 
  MIT Student
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"

>X-Sender: deliriem@hesiod
>X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0.2 
>Date: Fri, 05 Oct 2001 00:10:48 -0400
>To: ktwass@mit.edu
>From: Emily Cofer <deliriem@MIT.EDU>
>Subject: Fwd: Marilee Jones (Dean of Admissions) on the New Improved
>  MIT Student
>
>>Date: Tue, 2 Oct 2001 11:04:14 -0400
>>From: Richard Tibbetts <tibbetts@MIT.EDU>
>>To: mit-talk@mit.edu, ec-discuss@mit.edu, senior-house@mit.edu,
>>        savemit@mit.edu, iltfp-forum@mit.edu
>>Subject: Marilee Jones (Dean of Admissions) on the New Improved MIT Student
>>User-Agent: Mutt/1.3.22i
>>Sender: Richard Tibbetts <tibbetts@innocuous.mit.edu>
>>
>>The following appeared in last month's faculty newsletter. The faculty
>>newsletter is available at http://web.mit.edu/fnl/. People might want
>>to get in the habit of reading it, as another source of information
>>about what is going on at MIT.
>>
>>As brought to you by lynx -dump, from:
>>http://tute.mit.edu:8002/afs/athena/org/f/fnl/www/901/marilee_jones.htm
>>
>>                   Observations on the Newest Generation
>>                              of MIT Students
>>
>>                              Marilee Jones
>>
>>   One  of  the  great  pleasures  of  working  in Admissions is that I'm
>>   afforded  a  bird's  eye  view  of American teenage culture. While the
>>   freshman application has changed little over time and 17-year-olds are
>>   always  the  same in some fundamental ways, the attitudes, values, and
>>   activities  of our applicants do change quite dramatically each decade
>>   or  so,  heralding  the  arrival  of  a new generation. This shift has
>>   occurred  again  and  the  leading  edge of this newest generation now
>>   fills  all  four  undergraduate  classes at MIT. These students are as
>>   different  from  us  as  we  were  from our parents' generation. Their
>>   characteristics  bode well for society as a whole, but not necessarily
>>   for  MIT as it is today. Their presence will provoke a reevaluation of
>>   our  purpose  and  mission and they will challenge all of us adults to
>>   lead them in ways we are not expecting. They will change MIT as surely
>>   as MIT will change them. And I'm not sure we're ready for them.
>>
>>
>>   The Generations:
>>
>>   First,  by way of background, let's consider the different generations
>>   represented   at   MIT  today.  A  quick  comparison  of  generational
>>   characteristics  captures  the obvious differences among them. I refer
>>   here  to  Rocking  the  Ages:  The  Yankelovich Report on Generational
>>   Marketing,  Walker  Smith  and Anne Chirman, '97, which describes four
>>   twentieth-century generations: Matures, Baby Boomers, Generation X and
>>   Millennials.  (N.B.:  These  generalizations  are meant to capture the
>>   overall  characteristics  of the given population, not necessarily all
>>   individuals within it.)
>>
>>   The first group, labeled Matures, includes the World War II generation
>>   as  well  as the following Silent Generation. Matures, made up of 61.8
>>   million  members born between 1909 and 1945, were affected most by the
>>   key  markers  of the Great Depression, the New Deal, World War II, the
>>   GI  Bill.  As a result, the key characteristics of this group are team
>>   work,   commitment,   sacrifice,   discipline,  financial  and  social
>>   conservatism. (They are also known to the following generation as "The
>>   Establishment.")  Most  of the senior administration at MIT is made up
>>   of Matures.
>>
>>
>>   Baby  Boomers,  born  between  1946  and  1964, are the largest single
>>   generation  in US history at 77 million members. They were affected by
>>   Vietnam,  TV,  Woodstock,  Watergate,  and, of course, sex, drugs, and
>>   rock  and  roll. Boomers are characterized by idealism, individualism,
>>   self-improvement,  high expectations and an intense self-centeredness.
>>   Most  current  faculty  members  are Boomers, as well as a little over
>>   half  of  all  student  services administrators, including the Dean of
>>   Admissions.
>>
>>
>>   Generation  X,  born between 1965 and 1978, is the smallest population
>>   of the four at 52.4 million members. They were at the epicenter of the
>>   cultural meltdown brought about by the Baby Boomers in their effort to
>>   separate  from  the  Matures.  As a result, members of this cohort are
>>   characterized by pragmatism, diversity, entrepreneurial spirit, desire
>>   for  a  high  quality  of  life, savvyness. They were most affected by
>>   AIDS,  MTV, PCs, divorce, the Internet. This resourceful and resilient
>>   generation  created  the  dot  com  phenomenon. Nearly half of student
>>   services administrators are Gen Xers.
>>
>>
>>   Millennials,  the  newest generation, are the subject of this article.
>>   Born  after 1979, they will nearly eclipse the Baby Boomers in size at
>>   just  under  77  million members (and growing). The Yankelovich Report
>>   describes their markers as OJ, Monica Lewinsky, and multi-culturalism.
>>   I  would add the Columbine shootings to that list. Key characteristics
>>   of  this  group are neotraditionalism, ritual, optimism, technological
>>   adeptness, volunteerism, busyness.
>>
>>   We  can see the presence and the impact of these different generations
>>   at  MIT  over  time in [7]Table #1. As you know, all varsity teams and
>>   activities  at  MIT have been started by students. The 60% increase in
>>   varsity  team offerings between 1970 and 1990 was the direct result of
>>   Title  9  which mandated gender equity in athletic offerings in public
>>   schools. The doubling of MIT clubs between 1980 and 1990 came about as
>>   a  result  of  Gen  X  students who, used to finding community through
>>   common   interests,   created  a  plethora  of  ECAs  (extracurricular
>>   activities),  quite a different model of community building from their
>>   Boomer predecessors who connected through larger social movements. The
>>   doubling again of clubs and activities between 1990 and 2000 indicates
>>   the  recent  presence  of  the  Millennials. Though there is no way to
>>   actually  know,  I would posit that the number of ECAs carried per MIT
>>   student  now  is  higher  than in years past. Millennials, as we shall
>>   see, are extremely busy people.
>>
>>   While I agree with the Yankelovich summary of Millennials, I'd like to
>>   share  my  own observations of this new generation as seen through the
>>   MIT  application  process,  through the changing trends in the essays,
>>   activities,  letters  of recommendations, interview reports. I preface
>>   this  with the clear understanding that I am discussing MIT applicants
>>   from  the  US (a specialized group to be sure). I am also generalizing
>>   like  crazy,  since  we  are  now seeing just the leading edge of this
>>   amazing  group,  the  peak  number  of  which  has just entered middle
>>   school.
>>     * They are idealistically pragmatic. Combining the idealism of their
>>       Boomer  parents and the pragmatism of the Gen Xers, these students
>>       really   want   to  make  the  world  a  better  place  and,  most
>>       importantly, they have a plan.
>>
>>     * They  are  group  centered.  As  the  population  with the highest
>>       percentage  of  members  in  day care from an early age, they have
>>       learned good group skills, how to lead and follow as circumstances
>>       demand.  They  spend more time in groups and group activities than
>>       their predecessors.
>>
>>     * They  have  no  problem  with  authority. These students have been
>>       raised  in relative affluence in peacetime by Boomer parents. Most
>>       of  their  free time is spent in adult-supervised activities. They
>>       have  little  urge  to  push  back  against  adults. In fact, they
>>       actually  like  adults.  This  is shocking to both Boomers and Gen
>>       Xers  who  still  regard  authority  figures  with  suspicion, but
>>       Matures find a certain resonance with them.
>>
>>     * They are attracted to large social movements, very much like their
>>       Boomer parents, but look for ways to make their contributions on a
>>       local  level,  more  like  the  Gen  Xers. They are expected (even
>>       required)  to volunteer in their communities, working side by side
>>       with   adults   who   teach  them  competence  and  effectiveness.
>>       Consequently,  they  know  how  to work the system and they always
>>       have  a Plan B. Many of our students have already made significant
>>       contributions to their communities while still in high school.
>>
>>     * They  are not as likely to study subjects for the pure pleasure of
>>       it,  not  as  likely  to  focus on one thing, because they are the
>>       busiest  students in US history. The majority of my audiences this
>>       age  seem  to  carry  upwards  from  eight ECAs in high school, in
>>       addition  to  a  stiff  course  load.  (I  wonder when these teens
>>       actually   sleep.)  They  have  essentially  been  trained  to  be
>>       generalists.  Consider the tension created when MIT Mature, Boomer
>>       and   Gen   X   faculty,  who  are  living  their  passion,  teach
>>       Millennials,  who  want  to learn the material just well enough to
>>       get  a  good  grade so they can move on to the other 17 activities
>>       they  have  to  master that day. This has the makings of a classic
>>       generation gap.
>>
>>     * They  desire  instant  gratification.  A  member  of the Financial
>>       Services staff remarked recently that these kids "have never heard
>>       a  busy  signal." They are used to surfing the Web and they prefer
>>       Instant  Messaging  to  the phone for the sake of efficiency. (Why
>>       have a conversation with just one friend when you can speak with 8
>>       simultaneously?)  With  Boomer  parents who demand top service and
>>       strive to meet their childrens' every need, these kids expect what
>>       they want when they want it from all of the adults in their lives.
>>
>>     * They  may  not  see  or accept the consequences of their behavior.
>>       Adults  are  always  saving these kids. I see that top high school
>>       students   who  fail  exams  or  miss  deadlines  due  to  outside
>>       commitments  are  regularly protected by their teachers and school
>>       personnel.  Excuses  are made, adults blame themselves rather than
>>       allow the student to accept the painful consequences that previous
>>       generations  knew all too well. Parents do most of the negotiating
>>       with  admissions offices now, regularly weighing in on every piece
>>       of  the  process  on  behalf  of their busy children, taking on an
>>       almost  eerie  quality  of  parent-as-applicant.  No surprise that
>>       students  cheat more often, drop activities if they can't win, cut
>>       corners.  Their  time is all carved up, given away to multiple and
>>       competing  demands  that  please  adults while the adults in their
>>       lives race to protect them from failure.
>>
>>
>>   Is MIT a good match for this generation?
>>
>>   In  many  ways,  we  are  a  good  match for them. These kids are hard
>>   workers,  carrying  up  to a third more courses in high school than we
>>   did  at  their age, so the MIT workload isn't as big an issue to them.
>>   They  can  balance  competing  demands.  MIT is the firehose. They are
>>   diverse  and  require diversity. You can't find a more diverse private
>>   university  in  the  US than MIT. They can lead or follow as required,
>>   and  there  are  plenty  of opportunities to do both here. They desire
>>   relevant  work. We're all about relevance, eschewing ivory tower. They
>>   are intensely busy. Busy is our middle name.
>>
>>   But  in  many  more  ways  I worry about the match. First, while these
>>   Millennials  are  busy,  they  are  "diverse"  busy,  spreading  their
>>   energies  over  many activities, not the "focused" busy of the classic
>>   Techie,  who  eats,  sleeps,  and  dreams  their  passion. They desire
>>   structure  when  we are all about choice. They don't consider "choice"
>>   to  be  a value as the Boomers and Gen Xers do. These kids were raised
>>   on  the  World Wide Web and 90 channels of cable. They do not need 30+
>>   choices  of living groups - they are busy...they just want a room. You
>>   can  see  the  evidence  for  this  attitude in [8]Table #2, the chart
>>   listing  the  top  reasons why admitted MIT applicants chose to enroll
>>   elsewhere.  Last  year, for the first time, housing and the quality of
>>   the  campus,  was  the #3 reason why the students we worked so hard to
>>   admit  went  to other schools. This year, the quality of student life,
>>   which  includes  housing  and campus issues, was #2 on that list. This
>>   generation  is  voting  with its feet. The current housing system with
>>   its myriad choices and arcane rules, an artefact of the Boomer era, is
>>   no  longer  relevant to the students of today. MIT housing is changing
>>   just in time.
>>
>>   Most  disturbing  to me, though, is that the MIT Millennials, who have
>>   been  raised  on  praise  and positive re-enforcement, are in for real
>>   culture  shock.  They  have been groomed to high achievement, feted by
>>   their schools and communities, have starred in USA Today as well as in
>>   their  local  papers,  have been cheered in their games by adults from
>>   both  sides.  They  have  nearly  all  earned  at  least  state  level
>>   distinction in something. Think about that for a second. What would it
>>   have  taken  to be the state's best something when you were their age?
>>   It  is  a  big  deal  and  they could not have gotten that far without
>>   positive support from the adults in their lives. As we all know, there
>>   is  very  little of this at MIT, for any of us. These students come to
>>   MIT,  ready for us to lead them and position them for the next logical
>>   progression  of their lives and they quickly disengage from us because
>>   we  do  not  recognize their specialness. These are not Boomers or Gen
>>   Xers who reacted to this phenomenon by angrily pushing MIT faculty and
>>   administrators  away  and creating their own islands of support. These
>>   students  wonder  why  we  glorify  the  Big Screw Award, why the only
>>   campus-wide  community sentiment is IHTFP, why we tolerate the Tech Is
>>   Hell  lifestyle.  They  wonder  why  they turned down Stanford to come
>>   here.
>>
>>
>>   Why should we care or try to change?
>>
>>   It  is  no surprise that I am writing this as Dean of Admissions. Many
>>   faculty  who have worked with the Admissions staff and with CUAFA know
>>   well  that  we  are  in  a  tough  period  in  college admissions. Our
>>   competition   (Harvard,   Stanford,   Princeton,   Yale)  is  actively
>>   recruiting  our  kind  of  students  -  Techies - at a time when these
>>   students'  portfolios  are now so balanced they are just as attractive
>>   to liberal arts schools as they are to us. And everywhere universities
>>   are buying top talent. In short, we now have to work aggressively just
>>   to  continue  to  hold  our  base.  To  make things worse, Millennials
>>   require  a  sense of the larger community that can readily be found at
>>   our competitor schools. MIT, with its focus on the individual, without
>>   a  sense  of  campus-wide community, looks pale in comparison, like an
>>   outlier,  to these kids. MIT will need to adapt in some ways if we are
>>   to continue to enroll the best students of our type in the world.
>>
>>
>>   What they need from us
>>
>>   Millennials  need  MIT.  Despite  their  good qualities, and there are
>>   many,  these stunning young people need to learn to think analytically
>>   and  to  question more. They need a sense of context to help them sort
>>   through  the  dizzying mass of information they confuse for knowledge.
>>   And  closer  to this Boomer's heart, they need to realize that actions
>>   have  consequences,  so that in the future they will be less likely to
>>   hand  over  their  privacy  -  and  ours  -  for the sake of efficient
>>   consumer  service.  (They  don't  call  these  kids  "the  Abercrombie
>>   generation" for nothing.)
>>
>>   Whether  we  acknowledge  it  or not, we adults at MIT do act "in loco
>>   parentis,"  playing a major role in the lives of our students. Just as
>>   we   expect   them  to  meet  our  needs  regarding  deadlines,  class
>>   participation,  attention  to  detail, etc., they need specific things
>>   from us in order to thrive here.
>>     * They  need  to  understand the rules. For example, we can't assume
>>       that they actually know what is considered cheating these days. It
>>       is possible that they do not realize that pulling something off of
>>       the  Web  and  not  citing the source is a bad thing. I understand
>>       that  cheating cases of this sort have escalated in the past three
>>       years  at  MIT, so I encourage you to clearly define your rules at
>>       the  beginning  of  each  semester,  describe the repercussions of
>>       violating your rules and then follow through if violation happens.
>>       Remember  that  most adults in their lives cave in to them easily,
>>       so  they  will  push  back  hard.  Stand firm through all of their
>>       excuses  and  whining.  Eventually they will realize that you mean
>>       business  and they'll comply because Millennials generally want to
>>       obey the rules.
>>
>>     * They  need  to hear about MIT's history and relevance in the world
>>       and  to  be  reminded  why they are here. This is a big one. These
>>       students know that they are special and they have a sense that MIT
>>       is,  too.  Yet,  once they arrive on campus, they never again hear
>>       about  why  MIT  is  so  famous. I believe that this is one of the
>>       reasons  why  generations of bright-eyed MIT students, the best in
>>       the  world, have become disconnected, often cynical, by the end of
>>       their  freshman  year.  It  is not the workload alone, but a total
>>       lack  of  inspiration.  This  past  spring I spoke at a leadership
>>       seminar  on  campus. One of the students told me, in passing, that
>>       he  had  not  been  doing well in an advanced course taken by many
>>       freshmen  until  the  professor  spent an entire class on the many
>>       ways   that  MIT  specifically  advanced  that  particular  field,
>>       describing  the  history, the people, the same labs operational on
>>       campus  today.  The student was energized when he realized that he
>>       was  part of that legacy. He saw the relevance of the material. He
>>       concluded  the  semester  with  an "A" and the confirmed desire to
>>       become  a scientist. There is a great lesson here for everyone who
>>       teaches  at  this  remarkable  place.  Our  competition  tells its
>>       students  that  one  day  they will inherit the world as it is. We
>>       need  to tell our students that one day they will fix the world on
>>       behalf  of the others who can't. This is not only the truth. It is
>>       the  clarion  call to this generation, the mother ship calling the
>>       baby  ships  home.  I  believe that if we remind our students on a
>>       regular  basis  that we fix this world, we do what others think is
>>       impossible, we "apply science for the benefit of humankind" as MIT
>>       was  founded  to  do, and they are part of that effort, IHTFP will
>>       dissolve  within  five  years. And the best of our kind of student
>>       will continue to come to MIT for another generation.
>>
>>     * They  need to be involved in decision making, but they need for us
>>       to  make  the  final  decisions.  We  Boomers in particular have a
>>       tendency  toward  consensus  even when consensus is inappropriate.
>>       They don't want us to be friends. They want us to lead.
>>
>>     * They  need  praise  and positive feedback. At MIT, we put too much
>>       stock  in  perspiration  and not enough in inspiration. Because we
>>       think  analytically  for  a  living, it is often hard to keep that
>>       skill,  designed  for  the  world of ideas, from spilling into our
>>       social   discourse.   We  can  inadvertently  become  critical  of
>>       ourselves and of others. These students serve to remind us that we
>>       adults  hold  a  special  responsibility to encourage these future
>>       leaders  of  the world with words of kindness as we teach them the
>>       ropes.
>>
>>     * They  need  to  be  allies  with  us. MIT undergraduates have long
>>       existed in what I call a Lord of the Flies World in which, without
>>       adult intervention and engagement, they create their own rules and
>>       live  with  more  danger than we might imagine. These new students
>>       will  increasingly  find  this to be unacceptable because they are
>>       used to alliance with adults. Many of us will need to be more open
>>       to such alliance opportunities as Millennials enroll in force over
>>       the next decade.
>>
>>
>>   From  my  point  of  view,  the  future looks bright. If we assume our
>>   natural  role as the wise elders of this community during their tenure
>>   at  MIT,  and  if  we  apprentice them well, the world will be in good
>>   hands  with  these  Millennials. Not only will this huge population of
>>   very  hard  workers  who  care about community do good things in their
>>   lives,  they will never let Social Security fail. And that should help
>>   us all sleep a lot better tonight.
>> 
> 


------- End of Forwarded Message

