Return-Path: <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id XAA10368; Sat, 6 Oct 2001 23:43:41 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id XAA23398
	for <in-house-pikans@mit.edu>; Sat, 6 Oct 2001 23:43:41 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from tsuga (TSUGA.MIT.EDU [18.214.0.120])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with SMTP id XAA11193
	for <in-house-pikans@mit.edu>; Sat, 6 Oct 2001 23:43:40 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200110070343.XAA11193@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>
X-Sender: corrina@hesiod
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0.2 
Date: Sat, 06 Oct 2001 23:45:48 -0400
To: in-house-pikans@mit.edu
From: Corrina Chase <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Subject: no free speech at MIT
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"

This is nasty.  Write a letter to vest.  Use paper.
-ccc

>
>                              URGENT ACTION REQUESTED
>
>              MIT employee suspended and facing dismissal for voicing 
>         concerns about a multinational corporation's human rights record.
>
>Write letters to protect speech at MIT !!
>
>1) Write to President Vest and Chancelor Clay *respectfully* urging them
to look 
>   into this very serious matter. 
>
>2) Talk to your professors and encourage them to write or call President
Vest and 
>   and Chancellor Clay.
>
>3) Write to MIT Social Justice Cooperative at peace-keepers@mit.edu to get
involved.
>
>Details are given below. Forward this around, inside and outside of MIT. 
>More information also at: http://web.mit.edu/justice/www/acad_free.html
>___________________________________________________________________________
__________
>
>
>On thursday evening, a group of ethically concerned students attended a
>Shell Recruiting event in order to shed light on Shell's history in Nigeria. 
>The concerned students distributed flyers and asked questions to
recruiters about 
>this history. 
>
>An MIT employee, who works in the building where the recruiting event was 
>held, heard about the student's plans 30 minutes before it started and
decided 
>to join in. The employee, an administrative assistant, showed up after work 
>around 6:00 pm, and helped pass out fliers made by the students (see the
flyer 
>at http:/mit.edu/aram/Public/shell/why-shell.pdf and other Shell links at 
>http://mit.edu/aram/Public/shell). While the Shell representatives 
>were discussing Shell's policies on environmentalism and social
responsibility, 
>the MIT employee asked a question about Shell's role in pollution and human 
>rights abuses in Nigeria. Neither the MIT employee nor the concerned
students 
>present at the recruiting event were disruptive and their questions were
posed 
>in a respectful and polite manner. 
>
>The next day, the said MIT employee received a suspension notice which 
>claimed that he: 
>
>     "... passed out an inappropriate flyer against Shell Inc. 
>     on Thursday evening at a Chemical Engineering Graduate recruitment 
>     event lead by representatives of Shell Inc. Although document 
>     dissemination is a type of freedom of speech, the nature of what you 
>     passed out was inappropriate for an MIT employee ... as a result 
>     of your conduct last evening, you are being placed on a temporary 
>     suspension ... This suspension is immediate as of 5pm today, 
>     Friday October 5, 2001 ... the outcome will either lead to 
>     reinstatement of your appointment with BPEC/DMA or full 
>     dismissal." 
>          
>The employee was ordered to surrender his keys, VIP card and MIT ID card 
>as well as disclose passwords to his MIT e-mail account, desktop, etc. 
>
>Apparently, the Chem E. department told the suspended employee's supervisor 
>that he was considered a Chem E. "representative" since he works in the 
>building and was known by Chem E. people. In fact, it seems that the 
>MIT employee does not work for the Chem E. department, but for the 
>Dupont-MIT alliance (which has Chem E. professors in it, but is not under 
>the Chem E. department's authority).
>
>It seems that members of the Chemical Engineering department have difficulty 
>understanding the concept of free speech. The crucial decision makers of 
>this case in Chem E. are fine with free speech as long as it is speech they 
>agree with. MIT is a university, an institution of learning in which free
and 
>open debate is essential to its normal functioning. If merely questioning 
>a corporation is prohibited on campus by MIT staff because that corporation 
>gives money to MIT, we might as well stop calling MIT a university. 
>
>The actions against the MIT employee are a form of harrassment towards the 
>employee specifically and a very powerful form of intimidation to all 
>other MIT employees who will effectively be silenced from expressing their 
>views (even in off hours) because they fear losing their job. This 
>suspension sets a very disturbing precedent that will stifle free and open 
>discussion on campus of most issues. It is also a blatant abuse 
>of power by certain members of the MIT community that cannot be 
>tolerated. Immediate action must be taken by the MIT community and 
>the administration to rectify the situation. 
>
>Notes: 
>
>(1) Recruiting events are information sessions to educate MIT students 
>about a particular company. While Shell spent much time talking about 
>its initiatives on environmental policy and social responsibility, it 
>systematically avoided educating people at the event about its well 
>documented role in environmental pollution and human rights abuses. Since 
>the event is an educational occasion, MIT students and any other member 
>of the MIT community have the full right, in fact are obligated, for the 
>sake of balance, to fill in gaps in information that Shell 
>representatives systematically left out. What better place to do it 
>than at a meeting where Shell representatives are present to defend 
>the company's record ? 
>
>(2) Although the chemical engineering department claims they sponsored 
>the event, this is not mentioned on any of the flyers advertising the 
>event. One flyer was from Shell with no reference to MIT and another 
>flyer mentioned the MIT Career Services Office. The guidelines are very 
>clear on this. If an event is sponsored by several groups or departments, 
>they must all be listed on the event's flyers. If a group is not listed 
>as a co-sponsor on any of the flyers, they cannot claim that they 
>co-sponsored the event.  
>
>
>
>__________________________________________________________
>
>When writing emails, cc peace-keepers@mit.edu. Paper letters seem to be more 
>effective than email, but emails are also great.
>
>
>Practical info:
>
>      name: Vest, Charles M
>     email: cmvest@MIT.EDU
>     phone: (617) 253-0148
>   address: 3-208
>     title: President
>     alias: C-vest
>
>      name: Clay, Phillip L
>     email: plclay@MIT.EDU
>     phone: (617) 253-6164
>   address: 10-200
>department: Chancellor'S Office
>     title: Chancellor Professor Of City Planning
>     alias: P-clay
> 
> 
------------------------------------
-Corrina Chase
http://web.mit.edu/corrina/tpool/tidepool.html


