Return-Path: <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Received: from central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id VAA26044; Tue, 9 Oct 2001 21:13:19 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (MELBOURNE-CITY-STREET.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.86])
	by central-city-carrier-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id VAA26455;
	Tue, 9 Oct 2001 21:13:17 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from tsuga (TSUGA.MIT.EDU [18.214.0.120])
	by melbourne-city-street.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with SMTP id VAA12148;
	Tue, 9 Oct 2001 21:13:13 -0400 (EDT)
Message-Id: <200110100113.VAA12148@melbourne-city-street.mit.edu>
X-Sender: corrina@hesiod
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0.2 
Date: Tue, 09 Oct 2001 21:15:42 -0400
To: nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu, nchase@wcn.net
From: Corrina Chase <corrina@MIT.EDU>
Subject: Fwd: bad news
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Is this accurate?
-ccc
>
> X-Sender: sanjayb@hesiod=20
> X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Pro Version 4.0=20
> Date: Tue, 09 Oct 2001 08:24:36 -0400=20
> To: utr-announce@mit.edu=20
> From: Sanjay Basu=20
> Subject: bad news=20
> Cc: peace-list@mit.edu=20
>
> the summary:
>
> -at least 4 UN civilian workers have been killed by the bombings. u.s. and
> british warplanes hit a mine-clearing facility and killed them,
essentially a
> move to prevent the UN from clearing heavily-mined civilian areas.
>
> -AFP is trying to get a tally on the number of civilians killed. at this
> point, it looks like the number is hovering near 100, mostly women and
> children.
>
> -the world food program is stopping food distribution because of the=
 danger,
> and because u.s. forces won't inform them (even secretly) of where they=
 can
> safely deliver food. every major humanitarian aid agency has pulled out of
> afghanistan.
>
> -none of the airdropped food and medicine is useful. all were dropped
without
> parachutes from 30000 feet, exploding into bits on impact. essentially a
> propaganda measure...
>
> -UN offices came under attack by angry demonstrators in the Pakistani
city of
> Quetta today. The UN Children's Fund (UNICEF) office was burned, and the=
 UN
> High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) office was stoned. Five UN vehicles
> were burned. Damage was also reported at the office of the UN Special
Mission
> to Afghanistan in Quetta.
>
> some of the more detailed sources from which this information was=
 extracted:
> 1. MSF press release
> 2. NYTimes story
> 3. AFP brief
>
> MSF:
> MSF rejects link of humanitarian and military actions Airdrops of food and
> medical aid described as of 'negligible value' and 'potentially dangerous'=
=20
> Press release, Islamabad, Oct 8, 2001: The international medical aid=
 agency
> M=E9decins Sans Fronti=E8res (MSF), which has been working in Afghanistan=
 since
> 1979, today cast doubt on the so-called 'humanitarian airdrops' by US and
> British military forces, which have accompanied the military strikes=
 against
> Afghanistan over the last 24-hours. Such action does not answer the needs=
 of
> the Afghan people and is likely to undermine attempts to deliver=
 substantial
> aid to the most vulnerable.
>
> MSF's Dr Jean-Herv=E9 Bradol, speaking from Pakistan, explained that the
> so-called 'humanitarian' action, was in fact a purely propaganda tool, of
> little real value to the Afghan people.=20
>
> Moreover, the deliberate adoption by the military of a 'humanitarian'
> purpose, was likely to cause real problems for truly independent
> non-governmental aid organisations who are less likely to be perceived as
> impartial actors in the future.=20
>
> "How will the Afghan population know in the future if an offer of
> humanitarian aid does not hide a military operation?" questions Dr Bradol.
> "We have seen many times before, for example in Somalia, the problems=
 caused
> for both the vulnerable population and for aid agencies when the military
try
> to both fight a war and deliver aid at the same time."
>
> Dr Bradol explained that the real impact of the much-vaunted 37,500 single
> day rations on the burgeoning nutritional crisis within Afghanistan was
> likely to be minimal.=20
>
> "What is needed is large scale convoys of basic foodstuffs, rather than
> single meals designed for soldiers. Until yesterday the UN and aid=
 agencies
> such as ourselves were still able to get some food convoys into=
 Afghanistan.
> Due to the airstrikes the UN have stopped all convoys, and we will find
> delivering aid also much more difficult."
>
> Doctors from MSF also expressed concern at the reported airdropping of
> medical supplies. "Medical relief is not the same as dropping medicines by
> plane. Unless they are administered by qualified medical staff, medicines
can
> actually do more harm than good", said Dr Bradol. "Dropping a few cases of
> drugs and food in the middle of the night during air raids, without=
 knowing
> who is going to collect them, is virtually useless and may even be
> dangerous".
>
> M=E9decins Sans Fronti=E8res therefore rejects the idea of a humanitarian
> coalition alongside the military coalition, as requested by President Bush
> and Prime Minister Blair, and calls for the imperative necessity of
> independent humanitarian action.=20
>
>
> NYTimes:
> October 9, 2001
>
> THE ATTACK=20
> 4 U.N. Workers Killed in Initial Strike on Afghanistan
> By PATRICK E. TYLER
> Washington, Oct. 9 =97 The United Nations said today that four of its=
 workers
> were killed and four others were injured near Kabul in the latest round of
> bombing by the United States against Afghanistan.
> At a news conference in Islamabad, the Pakistan capital, a spokeswoman for
> the United Nations said that the workers were killed when a missile
destroyed
> a building housing Afghan Technical Consultancy, the agency that oversees
> mine clearing operations in Afghanistan. The building is several miles=
 east
> of Kabul, the Afghanistan capital.
> The spokeswoman said that all eight of the workers were Afghans and were
> civilians.
> It is the first independent report of civilian deaths resulting from the
> United States-led military action since the attacks began on Sunday.
> There was no immediate response from Washington on the deaths and
injuries to
> the United Nations workers.
> Afghanistan is one of the most heavily-minded countries in the world and=
 the
> United Nations began a mine-clearing program there last year.
> The United Nations appealed for the protection of civilians in the=
 military
> strikes against Afghanistan.
> For a second day, B-2 stealth bombers flying from the United States joined
> carrier-based aircraft on Monday to strike targets in Afghanistan as
> anti-American demonstrations began to roil Muslim capitals and Bush
> administration officials stepped up planning to oust the Afghan regime.
> Monday's bombing campaign sent aloft only about half the planes that
> President Bush ordered launched on Sunday in the first military response=
 to
> the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the United States. American warships
loosed
> Tomahawk cruise missiles in blazes of light over the Arabian Sea, and B-1
> bombers flew sorties from the island of Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean.=
=20
> Attacks seemed to be continuing on into daylight, however, suggesting that
> the Taliban's antiaircraft defenses had been weakened. The Associated=
 Press
> reported from Kabul, the capital, that a bomb fell near the airport after
> dawn today, followed by a missile screaming into the eastern part of the
> city. Senior military officials have said that attacks would continue=
 night
> and day.
> In Britain, Defense Secretary Geoffry Hoon suggested that the first phase=
 of
> attacks on Afghanistan could be over within days.
> "I anticipate it is more likely a matter of days rather than weeks," Mr.
Hoon
> told BBC television. "This is the first phase of our attacks on the=
 Taliban
> regime, on bringing Osama bin Laden to account."
> "It depends on how successful those attacks are and whether we find=
 further
> targets to address, but for the moment this is the anticipation," Mr. Hoon
> said.
> British forces joined the Americans in the first strikes against=
 Afghanistan
> on Sunday, but there was no word that they had taken part in the second
day's
> raids. An unidentified Defense Ministry official in London said they had
not.
> At the Pentagon, Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld said a preliminary
> assessment of raids against 31 targets on Sunday showed that "we have made
> progress" toward disabling military airfields and "eliminating the air
> defense sites" that protect the Taliban and the Qaeda terrorist network of
> Mr. bin Laden.
> Yet, he added, "we cannot yet state with certainty that we destroyed the
> dozens" of military command and leadership sites attacked by allied=
 aircraft
> and missiles. He said it was unclear whether the allied strikes had "fully
> disabled" the Taliban air force and air defenses.
> Still, Pentagon officials said, no Taliban aircraft have been seen taking=
 to
> the skies in opposition to American pilots, and no American planes have=
 been
> lost.=20
> As the night sky over Kabul was sundered by the flashes of bomb strikes=
 and
> the arcing lines of tracer fire, Mr. Bush sought to bolster antiterrorism
> forces at home by formally installing Tom Ridge, the former Pennsylvania
> governor, as the head of a new cabinet post for homeland defense. Yet=
 there
> were concerns that Mr. Ridge would lack the bureaucratic power to force
> dozens of agencies to coordinate efforts.
> "The best defense against terror is a global offensive against terror,
> wherever it might be found," Mr. Bush said at a swearing-in ceremony for=
 Mr.
> Ridge. "On all fronts, we are going to be ongoing and relentless as we
> tighten the net of justice."=20
> Mr. Rumsfeld said American warplanes had attacked Afghan ground forces
> associated with both Al Qaeda and the Taliban leadership under Mullah
> Muhammad Omar. Many of those forces are massed north of Kabul where they
have
> been fighting the opposition Northern Alliance, which is believed to be
> receiving covert assistance from Russia, Iran and =97 now =97 the United=
 States.
> Reports from Kandahar, a Taliban stronghold, said Mullah Omar's residence=
 at
> the edge of the city was destroyed during Sunday's opening attack, but
> Taliban officials said he and Mr. bin Laden were alive.
> The Taliban authorities estimated the death toll from the first day's=
 raids
> at between 8 and 20. American officials had no comment on possible
> casualties.
> Officers aboard the carrier Enterprise said their pilots had attacked an
> underground bunker on a hillside that was heavily defended by troops with
> small arms, but they declined to reveal the identity of the Taliban or Al
> Qaeda leaders who they believed were taking refuge there.
> As the American-led campaign unfolded, Palestinians clashed on Monday
with on
> another in the Gaza Strip. Palestinian security forces shot dead two
> students, one of them a 13-year-old, who were among up to 2,000 protesters
> demonstrating against the American-led military action in Afghanistan.=
 After
> the shooting, an angry crowd of Palestinians ransacked police posts in=
 Gaza
> City.=20
> The most widespread demonstrations against the American strikes occurred=
 in
> Pakistan, the world's second most populous Islamic nation and the breeding
> ground for many of the Islamic militants who now form the Taliban=
 leadership
> in neighboring Afghanistan.
> The worst anti-American demonstrations occurred in Quetta, a city 60 miles
> from the border with southern Afghanistan. At least one person was shot
dead,
> and police reported that a subinspector had been kidnapped when the=
 central
> police station was burned in rioting that destroyed several shops and=
 movie
> theaters. United Nations agency offices were also burned.
> Demonstrations occurred in the Pakistani capital, Islamabad, and in the
> cities of Peshawar, Lahore and Karachi, as well as close to the Khyber=
 Pass
> border crossing into Afghanistan, where tribal leaders burned an effigy of
> Mr. Bush.
> In Cairo, 10,000 students protested peacefully on three university=
 campuses,
> in one case chanting: "Our rulers, why are you silent? Have you got orders
> from America?"
> In Sudan, protesters in Khartoum shouted, "Long live bin Laden!"
> American embassies, schools and other facilities closed throughout the
Middle
> East as security alerts warned American citizens abroad to exercise=
 extreme
> caution.
> Although Iran expressed unusual sympathy for the United States in the
> aftermath of the Sept. 11 attacks and its Shiite Muslim leaders have no
> liking for the Sunni Muslim regime of the Taliban, the country's spiritual
> leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, condemned the American strikes.=20
> "America is lying when it propagates the aims of its attacks against
> Afghanistan to be a struggle against terrorism," he said. "But this is not=
 a
> struggle against terrorism. Why do they lie to the people of the world?=
 Why
> don't they express the true aim =97 power and domination."
> In his briefing on Monday, Mr. Rumsfeld said an American objective is to
> assist Afghan forces "interested in overthrowing and expelling" the
Taliban.=20
> "The United States is interested in the elements of the Afghans on the
ground
> that have it in their mind that they would like to end Al Qaeda's role in
> Afghanistan and end the senior Taliban's leadership role," Mr. Rumsfeld
said.
> "And the Northern Alliance and the tribes in the south and others are=
 among
> those."=20
> The White House spokesman, Ari Fleischer, said it was "not the job of the
> United States to engage in nation building" by seeking to orchestrate the
> shape of a future Afghan government. He reiterated administration policy,
> saying, "We do not want to choose who rules Afghanistan, but we will=
 assist
> those who seek a peaceful, economically developing Afghanistan, free of
> terrorism."
> Senator Joseph R. Biden Jr., chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee,
> said that "the Taliban is effectively already gone."
> Mr. Biden, appearing on the CBS News "Early Show," said the Taliban had
"lost
> the support of all the surrounding neighbors, adding: "It does not have=
 any
> place to go. And the question now is for me just a matter of how long, not
> if, and what replaces it."
> European Union foreign ministers, meeting in Luxembourg, declared that=
 "the
> Afghan people deserve a government which is truly representative and which
> responds to their needs and aspirations," and stressed that the United
> Nations had an "essential" role to play in establishing such a government.
> The French foreign minister, Hubert V=E9drine, said there was consensus on=
 a
> French proposal that Afghanistan's 86-year-old exiled king, now living in
> Rome, could play a key transitional role.=20
> Relief operations in Afghanistan suffered a blow on Monday when the United
> Nations World Food Program announced that it was suspending food
distribution
> in the country during the bombing campaign.=20
> American officials said C-17's flying at 30,000 feet again dropped more=
 than
> 35,000 food and medicine packets, but some international aid organizations
> criticized the effort.
> "It's an act of marketing, aimed more at public opinion than saving=
 lives,"
> Thomas Gonnet, head of operations in Afghanistan for the French group=
 Action
> Against Hunger, told Agence France-Presse.=20
> But Mr. Rumsfeld bristled at such criticism, pointing out that the United
> States had made a $320 million relief commitment to Afghanistan. One of=
 the
> purposes of the bombing campaign, he pointed out, was to make the country
> safe for relief operations to resume.
> At the United Nations, the American representative, John Negroponte,
> submitted a letter to the Security Council saying the United States may=
 find
> it necessary to carry its military campaign into other nations, without
> specifying which ones.=20
> "We may find that our self-defense requires further actions with respect=
 to
> other organizations and other states," the letter said, raising the=
 question
> of whether the Bush administration was laying the groundwork for attacks
> against terror groups in Iraq, Lebanon, Syria and other countries=
 identified
> as harboring terrorists.
> Jack Straw, the British foreign secretary, suggested that there was an
> agreement between London and Washington to defer actions elsewhere until=
 the
> Afghanistan problem was solved.=20
> "The agreement at the moment," Mr. Straw said in Luxembourg, is that
military
> strikes "are confined to Afghanistan." He added, "That is where the=
 problem
> is, and that is the military action in which we are involved."
> Mr. Hoon, the British defense secretary, told reporters in London that=
 "the
> use of ground troops" was among the options that American and allied
planners
> were preparing for later stages of the antiterrorist campaign in
Afghanistan.
>
> Canada said that it would contribute 2,000 troops, most of them commando
> forces, along with six ships and six aircraft to the American-led=
 coalition.
> And Chancellor Gerhard Schr=F6der of Germany, who has been keen to cast=
 his
> nation as a dependable Atlantic partner with a military contribution to
make,
> announced that he planned to visit Mr. Bush in Washington on Tuesday.
>
> AFP brief:
> KABUL, Oct 9 (AFP) - Four civilians working with an Afghan demining agency
> were killed during US-led strikes on Kabul, UN officials said, as the
> Taliban's supreme leader narrowly escaped a raid close to his home in
> Kandahar.=20
> The Taliban ambassador to Pakistan, Abdul Salem Zaeef, said Tuesday that=
 the
> US and British bombing raids and cruise missile attacks which began on
Sunday
> had killed "tens of civilians" in Afghan cities.=20
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------
> Sanjay Basu=20
> MIT
> 450 Memorial Drive=20
> Cambridge, MA 02139=20
> (617) 225-9497 (H)
> (208) 246-3519 (fax)
> (617) 560-9372 (pager)
> http://web.mit.edu/sanjayb/www
>
> for instant contact, e-mail:
> 6171779620@airtouchpaging.com=20



------------------------------------
-Corrina Chase
http://web.mit.edu/corrina/tpool/tidepool.html


