Return-Path: <lphelan@MIT.EDU>
Received: from grand-central-station.mit.edu by po11.mit.edu (8.9.2/4.7) id CAA01082; Mon, 15 Oct 2001 02:08:56 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (MANAWATU-MAIL-CENTRE.MIT.EDU [18.7.21.85])
	by grand-central-station.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id CAA15149
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@MIT.EDU>; Mon, 15 Oct 2001 02:08:55 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from buzzword-bingo.mit.edu (BUZZWORD-BINGO.MIT.EDU [18.7.16.73])
	by manawatu-mail-centre.mit.edu (8.9.2/8.9.2) with ESMTP id CAA13192
	for <nutso-flaming-pikans@mit.edu>; Mon, 15 Oct 2001 02:04:01 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from localhost (lphelan@localhost) by buzzword-bingo.mit.edu (8.9.3) with ESMTP
	id CAA06744; Mon, 15 Oct 2001 02:04:02 -0400 (EDT)
Date: Mon, 15 Oct 2001 02:04:02 -0400 (EDT)
From: Luke Phelan <lphelan@MIT.EDU>
To: <nutso-flaming-pikans@MIT.EDU>
Subject: one more
Message-ID: <Pine.GSO.4.30L.0110150200550.5103-100000@buzzword-bingo.mit.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII

okay, i'm forwarding one more observer article, this one about how much to
trust the news, and then i'm going to stop and tell you all to just go
read the observer online at http://www.observer.co.uk

this article at
http://www.observer.co.uk/waronterrorism/story/0,1373,573768,00.html

How much can we believe in the news campaign?

Jay Rayner tells how the war of words opens another

War on Terrorism: Observer special
War in Afghanistan: Observer special

Sunday October 14, 2001
The Observer

Tayseer Allouni knew exactly what to do when the first bombs started
dropping on the Afghan capital last Sunday night. As Kabul correspondent
for al-Jazeera, the Qatar-based Arabic news station and the only
television network with a presence in the city, he would have to be the
eyes of the world.
He turned the bureau's news camera on the night sky to record the tracer
fire now arcing impotently towards the incoming missiles. The pictures
were uploaded, via al-Jazeera's 24-hour satellite link, to the channel's
headquarters in Qatar, 1,200 miles away. From there they were picked up by
broadcasters across the world.

In London, the BBC's news producers saw the pictures and immediately
called the three correspondents they had managed to station in northern
Afghanistan with the opposition Northern Alliance on their satellite
phones. The BBC's journalists on the ground knew nothing of the attacks.
They had no way of knowing - Kabul is miles away across a country with no
modern communications network.

The correspondents, including John Simpson, had to be told by London that
the attack had started so that, a few minutes later, they could repeat the
news back to the viewers in Britain. 'It was all window-dressing,' one BBC
producer said last week. 'The reporters in Afghanistan didn't have a clue
what was going on.'

Richard Sambrook, head of news for the BBC, put it more delicately. 'Of
course, we told our correspondents what we knew in London,' he said, 'But
you don't just look to someone like John Simpson for a report on what
happened where they are 10 minutes ago. You want analysis.'

If ever there was a symbol of the challenges the media are facing in
covering the conflict, it is the distance the echo from those falling
bombs had to travel before it could be reported. There is a vast hunger
for information and the mass media with which to deliver it.

And yet this is a war without a frontline upon which to station reporters.
Unlike the Gulf War, when Peter Arnett of CNN was stationed in Baghdad,
and the Kosovo crisis, when Simpson was in Belgrade, the Western media
have no independent sources inside the battle zone.

'This will be a particularly difficult war for us to cover,' says the
BBC's defence correspondent Andrew Gilligan, now in Pakistan. 'Most of the
action will be invisible and there are no independent reporters able to
challenge the official version of events.'

As things stand, incidents such as the bombing of a refugee column during
the Kosovo crisis - first denied by Nato, and only admitted to when
journalists arrived at the scene - will this time round remain
unchallenged.

There is, simply, an aching information vacuum at the centre of this war
on terrorism, which sources on both sides of the conflict - both
governments and terrorists - are trying to fill. The result is an
increasingly difficult relationship between the US and British governments
on one side and Western journalists, who are not used to being brought to
heel, on the other. This weekend's announcement that the Blair Government
is to follow President Bush's lead by calling on UK broadcasters to think
carefully before allowing video-taped messages from Osama bin Laden and
the Al-Qaeda network on to the air, is proof of how tense that
relationship has become. In this conflict the mass media has become as
much of a weapon as the Tomahawk missiles launched from the Arabian sea
last weekend, only one that's less easily targeted.


The first of those contentious videos aired on Sunday night, as the bombs
were dropping. One of Osama bin Laden's couriers emerged in Kabul to
deliver a video-taped message for the world from his leader to the
al-Jazeera bureau. It was broadcast live to Qatar.

'From a journalistic point of view, the mere fact that the tape included
bin Laden's face for the first time since 11 September made it important,'
says Yosri Fouda, deputy executive director of al-Jazeera's London bureau.
'And he expressed joy at what had happened, which was also important.'

The next day, Tony Blair, dismayed at bin Laden's assertion that the West
was mounting a war on Islam, appeared on the same channel to rebut the
allegation.

By the end of the week, however, following al-Jazeera's decision to screen
another al-Qaeda message, this time promising more terrorist attacks, the
news channel was no longer a route to hostile Arabic public opinion for
the Western alliance. Now it was interpreted as a part of the hostile
public opinion.

According to Condoleezza Rice, National Security Adviser to President
Bush, the tapes could contain coded messages to terrorist cells, spurring
them into action. In a telephone conference call last Wednesday morning
with the presidents of the big five US networks, she called on them to
stop broadcasting the messages.

Afterwards, the US broadcasters, carefully walking the line between being
seen to serve both journalistic freedom and the US national interest, said
they had taken on board what had been said. 'After hearing Dr Rice we're
not going to step on any of the landmines she was talking about,' said
Walter Isaacson of CNN.

Richard Sambrook of the BBC, speaking before this weekend's announcement
from Downing Street, says no such pressure had yet been brought to bear.
Nor would the BBC be swift to oblige if it were. 'This idea that the tapes
may contain hidden messages is very hard to prove or disprove,' Sambrook
says. 'I think it's up to governments to show this is a serious issue
rather than merely raise the possibility.'

Certainly, it seems unlikely there were hidden messages within that second
tape. Unlike the bin Laden tape, the second was heavily edited before
being shown and there was no way its creators could have known which parts
would be cut. 'They really go on and on in rhetoric,' says Yosri Fouda of
al-Jazeera. 'We left just enough of it for them to make their point.'

However, the BBC has been the focus of other complaints from the
Government. Last Wednesday morning, the BBC's Kate Adie inadvertently
revealed Tony Blair's travel plans during his diplomatic mission to the
Middle East, which Downing Street had asked the media to keep secret.

The next morning Sambrook went on BBC Radio 4's Today programme to discuss
the row and again revealed something of the Prime Minister's movements.
'It would have been better for everybody had I not named the cities,' he
said afterwards. 'I should just have referred to the Middle East. But I
didn't actually give the itinerary and in any case the information was
already available on the international wire services.'

Sambrook's point, that the modern media are not linear, with information
going in one end and coming out the other, but far more complex and less
controllable, is a factor with which Western governments are still trying
to wrestle.

Last week, President Bush expressed outrage that a CIA report indicating
it was '100 per cent certain' there would be further terrorist attacks in
the US, had found its way to the press. 'Officials are really dismayed
about how much information is getting out here both on the terrorist
investigation and the military preparations,' says Kevin Whitelaw, a
reporter covering security matters in Washington DC for the American
magazine US News and World Report.

Bush said the information supplied to Congress, whose members he believed
to be the source of the leaks, would be limited. He was swiftly forced
into a U-turn by Senators and Representatives from both sides of the
political divide. The irony is that the US media have already proved
willing to comply with military orders when it matters. Seventeen news
organisations knew three days before that the bombing of Afghanistan was
to start on Sunday, and said nothing.

In London, attempts to control the media have been equally clumsy.
'Initially, the Ministry of Defence told us they would like us to clear
our stories with them,' says war correspondent Robert Fox, now with the
Evening Standard, who has covered conflicts from the Falklands war to the
Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan and the wars in Bosnia. 'We told them
that was not the game at all. They also discouraged us from going to other
sources. Someone like me, who has many contacts within the military, is
simply a complete pain to them.' The Ministry of Defence denies trying to
control coverage.

The real problem for Western politicians trying to hold together a fragile
international coalition is that the media have great power to magnify.
Footage of Palestinians on the West Bank celebrating the 11 September
attacks was hugely damaging to a Palestinian Authority desperate not to
enrage the US, even though the crowd numbered no more than 15 to 20.

Those numbers were irrelevant. The images still went about the world. (It
led to claims that the footage was a fake, recycled from the Allied
invasion of Kuwait; the claim has been investigated by the BBC and firmly
rebutted.) By last Friday, the authorities in the Gaza Strip were banning
reporters from the area, and arresting newspaper editors, to prevent them
covering a rally by Islamic militants.

But it is not only the tiny Palestinian Authority that is falling foul of
the media's reach. James Rubin, former Assistant Secretary of State in the
State Department during the Clinton administration who regularly briefed
the press during the Kosovo crisis, says the same is happening to the Bush
administration. And this has contributed to hostile Arab public opinion.

'Perhaps because they're new to the job, some of the officials are not
realising their every word is going around the world due to the global
nature of television,' Rubin says. 'The secret to a good briefing is to
have both a domestic and a foreign element. But because the original
attack was on New York and the USA there's now a very America-centric
flavour to the briefings.'

The White House press spokesman, Ari Fleischer, formerly Bush's campaign
spokesman, has come under particular attack. In one infamous briefing,
shortly after 11 September, he warned Americans to 'watch what they say'
and was immediately accused of trying to smother dissent, especially in
the media. The language was a mistake - Fleischer later admitted as much -
but he had pointed up the clear conflict between a country trying to wage
war and the modern media trying to report it. The age of deference has
gone.

And yet, as Tony Blair said last Thursday, there is still a propaganda war
to be won; one that may be even more important than the shooting war. 'One
thing becoming increasingly clear to me is the need to upgrade our media
and public opinion operations in the Arab and Muslim world,' Blair told
reporters on his plane from Oman. 'There is a need for us to communicate
effectively.'

The truth is, however, that neither he nor President Bush controls the
media. As each complicated day of this conflict passes, that is becoming
ever clearer.




