Course»Course 21W»Spring 2008»21W.747.02:»Homepage

21W.747.02:  Rhetoric of Science

Spring 2008

image restricted to class participants

ScienceDaily ( May 12, 2005 ) — A paper published in Nature on May 12th (1) provides new data that resolves a long-standing scientific controversy. In the 1960s, Nobel Prize winning zoologist, Karl von Frisch, proposed that honeybees use dance (the“waggle dance”) as a coded message to guide other bees to new food sources. However, some scientists did not accept von Frisch’s theory. Using harmonic radar, scientists, funded in part by the UK’s Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) have now tracked the flight of bees that had attended a “waggle dance” and found that they flew straight to the vicinity of the feeding site, as predicted by von Frisch. The tracks allowed the scientists to determine how accurately bees translate the dance code into successful navigation, and showed that they correct for wind drift even when en route to destinations they have never visited before. (See http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/05/050512114116.htm)

Instructor: Mya Poe

TA: Steven Strang

Lecture:  TR 11-12:30pm  (12-134)        

Information: 

“The rhetorical view of science does not deny ‘the brute facts of nature’; it merely affirms that these ‘facts,’ whatever they are, are not science itself. . . Whatever they are, the ‘brute facts’ themselves mean nothing; only statements have meaning, and of the truth of statements we must be persuaded. These processes, by which problems are chosen and results interpreted, are essentially rhetorical: only through persuasion are importance and meaning established”
- Alan Gross The Rhetoric of Science, p. 4

This course focuses on the ways that scientists use various methods of persuasion in the construction of scientific knowledge.

We’ll start with discussions about the nature of science and rhetoric. Then, we’ll turn our attention to texts written by scientists and use rhetorical theory to analyze those texts. We will look at the professional scientific research articles and other genres of scientific writing. Finally, we’ll investigate the way that rhetoric plays a role in the everyday life of scientists.

Through class discussions, presentations, and written assignments, you will get to practice your own rhetorical prowess. Through the readings, you’ll also learn some ways to make yourself a more efficient reader, as you use your analytical skills on the texts.

Announcements

Update on Final Class

Folks, I have changed my travel schedule so that I will be at MIT for the last day of class on Thursday. (I hate missing class!) Would you like to have class on Thursday or have Tuesday be our final meeting? Please email me with your preference. Mya

Announced on 09 May 2008  12:25  p.m. by Mya Poe

Final Papers and Portfolio

The end of the semester is very near so I wanted to clarify a few things about final due dates. Your final Project 2 paper is due this Friday, May 9th by the end of the day. I extended the time stamp on Friday until 11:59pm in case you wanted some extra time for your final draft.

Your portfolio review is due May 15th by the end of the day. Again, I extended the time stamp in case you wanted extra time on this project. A description of the portfolio assignment is available on the syllabus. We will actually draft part of your portfolio review in class on Tuesday (That’s May 13)


Any revised papers or extensions to the portfolio review must be submitted no later than Monday, May 19th. Grades are due on the 19th!

Cheers, Mya

Announced on 08 May 2008  1:48  p.m. by Mya Poe

Project proposal

Folks: Please upload your project proposal to the class stellar website and bring a copy to class tomorrow.
Many thanks, Mya

Announced on 14 April 2008  2:42  p.m. by Mya Poe

Your MIT Pictures

Please remember to send me your MIT pictures today. We will discuss them tomorrow at the beginning of class. See you then! Mya

Announced on 09 April 2008  10:05  a.m. by Mya Poe

presentation grades are posted

Your first presentation comments and grades are now available. Check the "comments" link with your presentation slides. Great job everyone!! Paper comments are on their way, too!--Mya

Announced on 07 April 2008  11:33  p.m. by Mya Poe

View archived announcements